top of page
Search

HE TAKETH AWAY THE FIRST: WHY IS CHRIST STILL BEING OFFERED FOR SIN?

Writer: Michelle Hayman
Michelle Hayman
21 minutes ago
57 min read
Hebrews 10:1–39 — The Sacrificial System in Which God Had No Pleasure, the One Offering That Ended It, and the Terrible Warning Against Rejecting His Covenant


If God declared that the repeated sacrifices of the law could never perfect the worshipper, that their continual offering exposed their inability to purge the conscience, and that He had no pleasure in that sacrificial order as the final answer to sin, why would He send His Son into the world merely to establish another system of recurring sin-offerings? More importantly, if the Son came expressly to fulfil the Father's will by taking away the first sacrificial order and establishing the second through the offering of His own body once for all, by what authority are Christians subsequently taught that Christ must continue to be presented to God as a propitiatory offering for sin?


These are not questions imposed upon Scripture from outside. They arise from the reasoning of Hebrews 10 itself. The writer does not simply declare that Jesus Christ is a greater sacrifice than the animals offered under the law. He explains what made the former sacrifices insufficient, identifies the result that a truly effective sacrifice would accomplish, and then declares that Christ has achieved precisely that result through one offering. The distinction is not merely between two kinds of victims, but between a sacrificial order that could never complete its work and an offering whose accomplishment brings that order to an end.

The argument reaches its decisive conclusion in Hebrews 10:18:

"Now where remission of these is, there is no more offering for sin."

These words do not stand alone. They are the consequence of everything established in the preceding seventeen verses. The writer has already explained why repeated sacrifices could not perfect the worshipper, why God had no pleasure in them as the final means of dealing with sin, why the Son came to fulfil His will, and how that will was accomplished through one offering. The conclusion is therefore not simply that Christ's sacrifice is more effective than the former offerings. It is that, having accomplished remission, His sacrifice leaves no further offering for sin to be made.


The New Testament does not leave the believer without a Mediator through whom the blessings of Christ's sacrifice may be received. Jesus Christ Himself is the ONE Mediator of the New Testament, and Hebrews specifically connects His mediation with His accomplished death and the inheritance promised to those who are called. The fact that forgiveness, mercy, sanctification, and spiritual blessings continue to be received after Calvary does not establish that the sacrifice must continue to be offered. Those blessings come through the efficacy of the sacrifice already made and through the living Mediator of the covenant established by His blood.


This distinction presents a serious difficulty for the Roman Catholic doctrine of the Mass, which teaches that Christ's sacrifice is made sacramentally present and offered through the ministry of priests for the living and the dead. The Catholic Church denies that Christ physically suffers or dies again in the Mass, maintaining instead that His one sacrifice is presented in a different manner and that its saving benefits are applied. That distinction must be represented accurately, but it does not remove the question raised by Hebrews: if the one offering has already accomplished the remission of sins, and the living Son is Himself the Mediator through whom the covenant's blessings are received, why does the New Covenant require the continuing sacrificial offering of Christ to obtain those benefits?


The issue cannot be resolved simply by saying that the Mass is unbloody, because Hebrews does not establish the finality of Christ's work merely by contrasting bloody and unbloody ceremonies. It establishes that finality by contrasting repeated offerings with one offering, unfinished cleansing with accomplished remission, and the continual ministry of standing priests with the Son who offered one sacrifice and sat down.

Nor can the distinction between Calvary and its sacramental representation be accepted as an answer without examining whether Hebrews permits the sacrificial presentation itself to continue. If Christ's sacrifice has accomplished the work, and the Mediator of the Testament continues to administer its blessings, the continuing availability of those blessings cannot automatically justify a continuing sacrificial offering. The application of a completed sacrifice is one thing; the necessity of continually presenting its victim in a propitiatory act is another. The latter requires its own scriptural authority.


There is also a distinction we must preserve from the beginning. The New Covenant has not abolished every kind of sacrifice. It has brought the recurring offering for sin to its appointed end. God’s people themselves—not a privileged religious hierarchy drawn from the wealthy, noble, and aristocratic classes of society—are called a royal priesthood, and Scripture expressly identifies the spiritual sacrifices they are to offer. They are to praise His name, give thanks, do good, share with others, and present their lives in holy obedience. The fact that sacrifice continues in this spiritual sense does not mean that the Son of God must continue to be presented as a victim for sin. Rather, these acceptable sacrifices arise because His one offering has already secured the believer's access to God.


This positive distinction is essential. If Scripture merely abolished sacrifice without explaining the worship that follows, there might be room to argue that the Church must devise a continuing sacrificial system. But the apostles do not leave that question unanswered. They identify believers themselves as a royal priesthood and describe the sacrifices that are acceptable to God through Jesus Christ. We therefore possess both sides of the argument: Hebrews tells us which sacrificial order Christ has brought to an end, while the New Testament tells us what sacrifices continue among those redeemed by His blood.


To understand the seriousness of this distinction, we must follow Hebrews 10 from its beginning to its conclusion, allowing the writer's own reasoning to determine what the New Covenant establishes and what it brings to an end.


If the Sacrifice Had Purged the Worshipper, Would It Not Have Ceased?

The chapter begins by identifying the nature and limitation of the former sacrificial order:

"For the law having a shadow of good things to come, and not the very image of the things, can never with those sacrifices which they offered year by year continually make the comers thereunto perfect." — Hebrews 10:1

The description of the law as a shadow is fundamental to everything that follows. A shadow anticipates something beyond itself, but it cannot perform the work of the reality it represents. The sacrifices prescribed under the law pointed toward the coming redemption, yet they did not possess the power to accomplish its final purpose. They were given for a time, within a covenant whose ceremonies anticipated a greater fulfilment, but they could never bring those approaching God through them into the perfected standing that Christ's sacrifice would establish.


Notice that the writer does not attribute this failure merely to the sinfulness of the priests or the disobedience of those who brought their offerings. The sacrifices are described as those offered "year by year continually," and their inability to perfect the worshipper is expressed in absolute terms: "can never."

Nor were these merely unauthorised sacrifices invented by men. The writer subsequently identifies them as offerings made according to the law. God had prescribed them within the former covenant, yet their existence did not mean that He intended their repetition to continue for ever. Their purpose was provisional, and their limitation was demonstrated by the very fact that they had to continue.


Verse 2 then introduces the question upon which the argument depends:

"For then would they not have ceased to be offered? because that the worshippers once purged should have had no more conscience of sins." — Hebrews 10:2

This is not a passing observation. It is the writer's explanation of why the repeated sacrifices were unable to accomplish the necessary perfection.

He asks whether they would not have ceased to be offered if they had truly perfected the worshipper. The expected answer is yes. If the worshippers had been purged in the sense intended, the continuing sacrificial remedy would no longer have been required for the same unresolved need.


This establishes an important relationship between the accomplishment of sacrifice and its cessation. The former sacrifices continued because they had not brought the worshippers to the completed cleansing under discussion. The repetition was not evidence of their final effectiveness but of their inability to reach that end.

The words "the worshippers once purged" deserve particular attention. The writer connects the effectiveness of sacrifice with a change in the conscience. Those who had truly been purged would have had "no more conscience of sins."


This cannot mean that believers would become incapable of wrongdoing, lose the ability to recognise sin, or cease to remember their past disobedience. Hebrews itself warns Christians against sin, calls them to holiness, and urges them to encourage one another toward love and good works. A conscience that no longer recognised evil would hardly be the result of having God's law written upon the heart.


The meaning must therefore be understood in relation to the sacrificial question being addressed. The worshipper remained conscious of sin as an unresolved burden before God, a burden for which the former sacrificial order could not provide final cleansing. The recurring offerings continually brought that liability before the worshipper because they could not accomplish the enduring remission that Christ would obtain.

The distinction between remembering wrongdoing and requiring another sacrifice for wrongdoing is crucial. A believer may recognise a sin and repent of it without concluding that Christ's offering has failed. He may grieve over his disobedience while continuing to trust the blood through which forgiveness has been obtained. The conscience cleansed through Christ is not a conscience made morally indifferent, but one no longer dependent upon a recurring sin-offering to establish access to God.


Now consider the implication of the writer's question. If the failure of the former sacrifices was demonstrated by their continuing necessity, what must be true of the sacrifice that succeeds where they failed? Surely the very purpose of Christ's offering must be to accomplish the cleansing whose absence made the former offerings necessary.

This is why the question cannot be dismissed as merely a criticism of animal sacrifice. Hebrews uses the failure of those sacrifices to establish what the offering of Christ must accomplish. If Christ's sacrifice is the reality to which the shadow pointed, it must produce the result that the shadow could never achieve.


The question may therefore be applied to any system that continues presenting Him as a sin-offering. If the offering of Christ has purged the believer's conscience, what sacrificial deficiency remains to be addressed by presenting Him again? If another presentation is required because the worshipper has not yet obtained the necessary cleansing, then what distinguishes that continuing need from the condition Hebrews identifies as evidence of the former order's insufficiency?


Here the argument must be especially precise, because the Catholic response is that the Mass does not complete an incomplete Calvary but applies the saving effects of an already sufficient sacrifice. If that is the answer, then the real issue becomes whether such application requires Christ to be offered sacrificially. The application of forgiveness is not itself proof that another offering has been made or is necessary. What Hebrews challenges is the need for a continuing offering for sin when the one offering has already achieved its purpose.


The proposition must therefore be separated into two claims. The first is that believers continue to receive forgiveness and grace through Christ's sacrifice. Hebrews gives every reason to affirm this. The second is that Christ must continue to be offered sacrificially for those benefits to be received. Hebrews 10 does not establish that second claim merely by acknowledging that the benefits of His death endure.

The distinction matters because otherwise the argument could be reduced to the weak assertion that anything repeated must be ineffective. Prayer is repeated, thanksgiving is repeated, and the Lord's supper is repeated. None of these repetitions proves that Christ's sacrifice failed. The repetition that Hebrews identifies as evidence of incompleteness is repetition in the offering of sacrifices that cannot bring the worshipper to the intended cleansing. What must be established is whether a later propitiatory offering belongs to the continuing sacrificial category that Christ's one offering has rendered unnecessary.


There is another question that follows from verse 2 and deserves careful attention. If a person continually approaches God through a ceremony understood to present Christ as a propitiatory offering, does that person understand the conscience to have been purged in the manner Hebrews describes, or does the worshipper remain conscious of an ongoing sacrificial liability that must be addressed through another offering? The occurrence of later sins does not establish that Christ's sacrifice has failed, for a completed offering can provide the basis of forgiveness for sins committed afterward. Nevertheless, if the believer is taught that an additional sacrificial presentation is required before those benefits can be received, the difference between an accomplished atonement and a continuing sacrificial remedy becomes decisive.


Hebrews does not tell the believer that Christ must be presented again in order for the value of His blood to become available. It directs the believer to the offering through which remission has already been secured, and later commands him to draw near in full assurance of faith. This is why verse 2 is not merely an historical explanation of Israel's sacrifices. It establishes a theological test concerning the relationship between purging the conscience and the necessity of continuing sin-offerings.

Verse 3 explains the character of the former repetition:

"But in those sacrifices there is a remembrance again made of sins every year." — Hebrews 10:3

The annual sacrifices did not finally settle the question of sin. Instead, the recurring ceremony brought sins to remembrance again. The worshipper returned to an offering because the former offerings had not accomplished the purging described in verse 2.

This does not mean the sacrifices were meaningless. They testified to the seriousness of sin, acknowledged the need for atonement, and anticipated the greater sacrifice to come. Yet the writer's immediate purpose is to identify their inability to remove the need for another offering.


The sequence is therefore important. Verse 1 establishes that the sacrifices could never perfect the worshipper. Verse 2 explains that, had they accomplished the necessary cleansing, they would have ceased. Verse 3 identifies their repeated remembrance of sins, and verse 4 gives the underlying reason:

"For it is not possible that the blood of bulls and of goats should take away sins." — Hebrews 10:4

The problem was not that the former sacrifices were offered insufficiently often. Neither was it that they needed to be performed through a different ceremonial method. Their very nature prevented them from accomplishing the final removal of sin.


God had not intended a succession of animal offerings to provide the ultimate cleansing of His people. They were a shadow pointing toward the one sacrifice capable of doing what they could never accomplish.

There is an important contrast here with Christ's command at the Last Supper. Hebrews 10:3 uses the Greek noun anamnēsis for remembrance, the same noun appearing in Luke 22:19 and 1 Corinthians 11:24–25 when Christ says, "This do in remembrance of me."

The shared word does not prove that the passages describe identical ritual acts. Hebrews speaks of sins brought to remembrance through the annual sacrifices, whereas Christ commands His disciples to remember Him. Nevertheless, the change in what is remembered is significant.

Under the former order, the recurring sacrifices brought sins to remembrance. At the Lord's supper, believers remember the One whose death accomplished the remission those offerings could never obtain.


Paul explains the purpose of this observance:

"For as often as ye eat this bread, and drink this cup, ye do shew the Lord's death till he come." — 1 Corinthians 11:26

The repeated actions described here are eating, drinking, and proclaiming the Lord's death. The fact that His death is remembered repeatedly does not mean that His sacrifice must be offered repeatedly. An accomplished event can be proclaimed continually precisely because its significance remains.


The timing of Christ's command is also relevant. When He gave the bread and cup to His disciples, His sacrificial death had not yet occurred. He spoke of the body to be given and the blood of the New Testament before the sacrifice at Calvary had been accomplished. The disciples were instructed to repeat the action of remembrance, but the recorded command does not expressly appoint them to continue presenting Him as a propitiatory victim for sin.

The institution of the supper looks forward to His approaching death; the observance described by Paul looks back upon that death and proclaims it until He comes. Neither the shared Greek noun nor the repeated act of remembrance, by itself, proves the establishment of a recurring sin-offering.


There is also a further difficulty in interpreting the words "This do" as a command to offer Christ. The immediate actions are the taking of bread, thanksgiving, breaking, eating, and drinking. An instruction to repeat these actions is present in the text. An instruction to offer Christ to the Father as a propitiatory sacrifice must be inferred from them. It cannot simply be substituted for their recorded meaning.


That distinction becomes particularly important when the death of the Testator is considered. Hebrews 9:16–17 explains that the death of the testator is necessary for the testament to come into force. Christ spoke of the New Testament in His blood before that death had occurred. The saving event toward which His words pointed was still to be accomplished, and the authority of the testament rests upon the death through which it was established.

A command given before that death may certainly govern the worship of the church afterward. But it does not follow that the command establishes a continuing sacrificial offering of the Testator Himself. The meaning of the command must still be demonstrated from the words spoken, rather than assumed from later sacrificial theology.


The central question remains: why would the remembrance of Christ's completed sacrifice require the continuation of the very sacrificial principle whose inadequacy Hebrews is exposing?


God Had No Pleasure in the Former Sacrificial Order

Having established why the former sacrifices could not perfect the worshipper, the writer explains what God intended in their place.

"Wherefore when he cometh into the world, he saith, Sacrifice and offering thou wouldest not, but a body hast thou prepared me: In burnt offerings and sacrifices for sin thou hast had no pleasure." — Hebrews 10:5–6

The word "wherefore" connects these verses directly to what precedes them. Because the blood of animals could not take away sins, the writer turns to the coming of the Son and the purpose of His prepared body.


These words do not merely announce that Christ will become a superior sacrificial victim. They introduce the will of God concerning the removal of the former order and the establishment of something it could never achieve.

We must not misunderstand the declaration that God had no pleasure in burnt offerings and sacrifices for sin. He had commanded such offerings under the law, and obedience to His commandments was not inherently displeasing to Him. The issue is whether those offerings were His final means of perfecting His people. Hebrews explains that they were not. Their repeated performance could not provide the completed cleansing God intended to establish through His Son.


Verse 8 reinforces this by identifying the offerings as those prescribed by the law. The writer is not merely condemning pagan worship or ceremonies performed unlawfully. He is explaining why even the lawful sacrificial order could not remain the final arrangement between God and His people.

This is a critical point. If sacrifices commanded under the former covenant were nevertheless incapable of accomplishing God's ultimate purpose, their lawful origin could not justify their indefinite continuation after that purpose had been fulfilled.


The Son's response is therefore decisive:

"Then said I, Lo, I come (in the volume of the book it is written of me,) to do thy will, O God." — Hebrews 10:7

Christ enters the world to fulfil the Father's will. The writer does not describe the Son as announcing that He has come to preserve the former sacrificial arrangement through an endless succession of offerings of Himself. Instead, the Son comes in obedience to accomplish what the former order could never achieve.

This difference becomes explicit in verses 8–9:

"Above when he said, Sacrifice and offering and burnt offerings and offering for sin thou wouldest not, neither hadst pleasure therein; which are offered by the law; Then said he, Lo, I come to do thy will, O God. He taketh away the first, that he may establish the second." — Hebrews 10:8–9

The first is taken away so that the second may be established. These are words of removal and fulfilment, not merely substitution of one victim for another within an otherwise unchanged sacrificial system.


The first belongs to the order of sacrifices that could not bring the worshippers to perfection. The second concerns the accomplishment of God's will through the obedience of His Son.

The distinction matters because the writer has not simply argued that God disliked the quality of the former victims and therefore desired more valuable victims to be presented repeatedly. He has established that the former sacrificial arrangement could never accomplish the necessary cleansing, and that the Son came to fulfil God's will in a way that would bring that arrangement to its appointed end.


We must therefore ask what exactly has been taken away. Hebrews is not abolishing praise, thanksgiving, obedience, or every possible use of the word sacrifice, for the same epistle later commands believers to offer sacrifices of praise and good works. Nor is it abolishing the heavenly priesthood of Christ, which remains central to the letter. What is removed is the former covenant's sacrificial arrangement as the means by which worshippers repeatedly approached God with offerings for sin that could not perfect them.


The issue is not whether Christians may use sacrificial language in worship. Hebrews itself does so. The issue is whether the offering of a victim for sin remains a continuing requirement after Christ's one offering has achieved what the former sin-offerings could never accomplish.

If the continuing offering is defended on the grounds that the New Covenant must possess a sacrificial system corresponding to the old, Hebrews 10:9 presents a direct objection. The writer's emphasis is not upon preserving that correspondence, but upon the removal of the first order so that God's will might be fulfilled through the second.

The next verse identifies precisely how this will is accomplished:

"By the which will we are sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all." — Hebrews 10:10

This sentence brings together the essential elements of the argument. The will of God is fulfilled; the believer is sanctified; the means is the offering of Christ's body; and that offering is once for all.

The writer does not say that believers are sanctified through an indefinite succession of offerings of Christ's body. He identifies one bodily offering as the accomplishment through which the Father's will is fulfilled.


If God's will required His Son to be offered continually for sin, one would expect the writer to explain how that continuing presentation belonged to the new order. Instead, Hebrews identifies the singular offering as the decisive fulfilment and immediately proceeds to contrast it with priests who continue offering sacrifices.

This is where the question concerning the Mass becomes especially pointed. Catholic theology does not claim that Calvary was insufficient or that Christ must undergo another bloody death. It teaches that the same sacrifice is sacramentally made present and offered in an unbloody manner.


Yet the question remains whether this teaching preserves the distinction Hebrews has established. The former order was not taken away merely because its victims were animals. Its recurring sacrifices could not complete the work of cleansing. Christ's offering is distinguished not only by the worthiness of His person but by the completion it accomplishes.

If the first order is removed because it cannot perfect the worshipper, and the second is established through one offering that does perfect, why must the defining activity of presenting a propitiatory sin-offering continue?


It is not sufficient merely to say that the manner has changed. The issue is whether God has commanded the continued sacrificial presentation of His Son after declaring the former order removed and the necessary sanctification accomplished.

There is a decisive difference between the Son continually exercising the benefits of His completed priesthood and the Son continually being offered as a sacrificial victim. The first follows naturally from the enduring efficacy of His work and the fact that He lives. The second needs to be established by the terms of the New Covenant rather than assumed from the existence of priesthood itself.

The Son did not come to establish the perpetual incompleteness of His own offering. He came to do the Father's will, and Hebrews declares that this will has been fulfilled through the offering of His body once for all.


The consequences of that fulfilment are explained in the following verses.


There is an additional point concerning the will of God that makes the later teaching about a continual propitiatory sacrifice especially difficult to reconcile with Hebrews. The writer does not merely assert that one sacrifice is preferable to many sacrifices. He announces that the Son's obedience fulfils the divine purpose for which the former arrangement existed, and that the first is consequently removed. If the recurring sacrificial offering of a victim for sin remains an essential requirement of worship after that fulfilment, then we must explain what has actually changed beyond the identity of the victim and the manner of presentation. The argument of Hebrews requires a deeper change than this, because the result of Christ's sacrifice is the perfected standing of the worshipper and the cessation of further sin-offerings.


If, on the other hand, the continuing sacrifices of the New Covenant are the spiritual offerings of those who have already been sanctified through Christ, the whole argument remains coherent. The first order of repeated offerings for sin has been removed; the Son has accomplished the necessary atonement; and His people now bring to God those spiritual sacrifices that flow from forgiveness and obedience. The continued existence of worship is thereby preserved without reinstating the recurring sacrificial presentation of a victim for sin.


The Priests Stand Daily; Christ Offered Once and Sat Down: Hebrews 10:11–18

The writer now presents the contrast between the former sacrificial ministry and the completed offering of Christ in its clearest form:

"And every priest standeth daily ministering and offering oftentimes the same sacrifices, which can never take away sins: But this man, after he had offered one sacrifice for sins for ever, sat down on the right hand of God." — Hebrews 10:11–12

These verses deliberately place two forms of priestly ministry in opposition.

The priest of the former order stands daily. His sacrificial work continues because the offerings do not finally take away sins. He must return to the altar because the previous offerings have not accomplished the perfection described in verse 1.


Christ, however, offers one sacrifice for sins for ever and sits down at the right hand of God.

The contrast is not simply that the former priests were morally imperfect while Christ is holy, although His holiness is essential to His priesthood. The writer draws attention to the differing character of their sacrificial work. One ministry is marked by recurring offerings; the other by an accomplished offering followed by the Son's enthronement.


This is why the references to standing and sitting matter. The former priests continually stand because their sacrificial ministry remains repetitive. Christ sits because His offering has achieved the work for which He came.

His sitting down does not mean He has ceased to live, reign, intercede, or exercise His priestly ministry. Verse 13 immediately describes Him awaiting the final subjection of His enemies. Nevertheless, the writer does not present His continuing heavenly ministry as requiring the continual offering of His body. He distinguishes the completed sacrificial act from the enduring life and reign of the Son.


Consider the implications for the claim that earthly priests must continually offer Christ as a sacrifice for sin.


If the writer intended to describe a New Covenant system in which Christ's sacrificial offering would continue through the ministry of priests, why would he establish his contrast by emphasising that the former priests offered repeatedly while Christ offered once? Why would he present the sitting Son as the counterpart to the standing priests unless the completed character of His offering were central to the distinction?


The Catholic reply is that the Mass does not constitute another Calvary but makes the one sacrifice present. This distinction prevents the claim that Catholics believe Christ undergoes another physical death. Yet it does not, by itself, establish that Hebrews authorises a continuing sacrificial presentation. The text must still be examined for evidence that the one offering which brought the former order to an end is intended to be offered continually through earthly priests.


There is a further difficulty. If a sacramental offering is said to be the same sacrifice, we must still distinguish the identity of the sacrifice from the occurrence of the sacrificial action. Saying that the victim is identical does not answer whether the repeated priestly act is required. The former priests could offer the same categories of sacrifices repeatedly, but their repetition was precisely what Hebrews contrasted with the one offering of Christ.

A defender of the Mass may answer that the sacramental action does not create another historical sacrifice, but makes the unique historical sacrifice present. That is the actual Catholic claim, and it should not be confused with the claim that Calvary occurs anew. Yet the language of a continuing propitiatory offering still requires an explanation in the light of Hebrews. Does the new sacrificial act accomplish something required for remission that Christ's one offering has not already accomplished, or does it merely make accessible the benefits of an accomplished offering? If the latter, why must the accessibility of those benefits be described as Christ being offered for sin, rather than as His continuing mediation and the believer's reception of forgiveness through faith?


Verse 14 explains what Christ's one offering achieved:

"For by one offering he hath perfected for ever them that are sanctified." — Hebrews 10:14

This verse must be read together with verse 2, because the writer is now declaring the accomplishment whose absence explained why the earlier sacrifices continued.


At the beginning of the chapter, the sacrifices could never make the worshippers perfect. If they had perfected them, the writer asks, would they not have ceased to be offered? Now he declares that Christ, by one offering, has perfected for ever those who are sanctified.

The relationship is exact. The former sacrifices could not perfect, and therefore they continued. Christ's offering does perfect, and the writer subsequently declares that no more offering for sin remains.

This is the decisive logic of the chapter.


The perfection must not be confused with sinless conduct or the absence of continuing spiritual growth. The people perfected through Christ's offering are described as those who are sanctified. Their lives must continue in faith, holiness, repentance, and obedience. But this continuing work in the believer does not establish that Christ's sacrificial offering remains unfinished.


There is a difference between an accomplished redemption whose benefits are received throughout the believer's life and a sacrificial work that must continually be performed to achieve its intended result. Hebrews attributes the believer's perfected standing to the one offering, not to a series of subsequent offerings.

The Christian who sins after receiving the gospel does not thereby demonstrate that Christ's original sacrifice was insufficient. He demonstrates his continuing need to repent, resist sin, and walk faithfully before God. His sin does not require another crucifixion, nor does Hebrews instruct him to seek another sacrificial presentation of the Son to complete the atonement.


This is where Hebrews' teaching about Christ as Mediator becomes decisive. A covenant may establish blessings that are received at different times without requiring the death by which the covenant was established to occur again. A person does not need a testator to die repeatedly whenever another beneficiary receives what the testament promises. The effectiveness of the testament rests upon the death by which it came into force.

Hebrews 9:15 explicitly identifies Christ as Mediator of the New Testament and connects the promised inheritance with His death. Verses 16–17 explain why that death was necessary for the testament to have force. The writer does not describe an arrangement in which the Testator must be sacrificially presented on each occasion that the inheritance is received. The death establishes the testament, and the covenant's blessings are received because that death has accomplished its purpose.


This analogy must not be pressed beyond the writer's own meaning. A covenant is not identical in every respect to an ordinary human will, and the passage does not establish that God can use no appointed means through which His grace reaches believers. What it does establish is that the decisive death has taken place and that Christ Himself is the ONE Mediator through whom the promised inheritance comes.


That matters greatly for the question of sacramental re-presentation. If Christ is the living Mediator of the testament established by His death, then the continuing reception of covenant blessings is already accounted for. He need not die again, and Hebrews 10 gives no instruction that He must be continually presented as a propitiatory victim whenever those blessings are received. His mediation is not an argument that His sacrifice remains unfinished; it is the means by which the benefits of His completed work continue to reach His people.

The writer then introduces the witness of the Holy Ghost:

"Whereof the Holy Ghost also is a witness to us: for after that he had said before, This is the covenant that I will make with them after those days, saith the Lord, I will put my laws into their hearts, and in their minds will I write them; And their sins and iniquities will I remember no more." — Hebrews 10:15–17

The significance of this testimony must not be overlooked.


The Holy Spirit is presented as a witness to the New Covenant, and the promise specifically concerns inward transformation and the remission of sins. God will put His laws into the hearts and minds of His people, and their sins and iniquities He will remember no more.

This directly answers the problem established at the beginning of the chapter.


The former sacrifices brought sins to remembrance again every year because they could not perfect the worshipper. The New Covenant promises that God will remember sins no more because Christ's offering has accomplished the remission those sacrifices could never provide.

The difference is not that God has become indifferent to wrongdoing. The very same covenant places His law within the believer. Forgiveness and holiness are therefore joined together. The believer does not receive permission to continue in sin; he is brought into a new relationship with God, in which the sacrifice necessary for remission has been accomplished and the law of God is written upon the heart.


The writer now draws the conclusion:

"Now where remission of these is, there is no more offering for sin." — Hebrews 10:18

The word "now" connects the statement to the covenant promise immediately preceding it. Because God has established remission through the one offering of His Son, no further offering for sin remains.

This is the verse by which every claim concerning a continuing propitiatory sacrifice must be examined.


It does not merely say that no more animal sacrifices are required. The writer has already explained why animal sacrifices were insufficient and why the Son's offering was necessary. His conclusion concerns the result of accomplished remission: where remission exists, no more offering for sin remains.


Nor does the verse say that a bloody offering is no longer required but an unbloody offering must continue. The writer makes no such qualification. He has already connected the cessation of sacrifice with the purging of the conscience, identified the Son's offering as once for all, and contrasted repeated priestly offerings with Christ's completed work.

Therefore, a teaching that establishes a continuing sacrificial offering of Christ for sin must explain how that offering differs from the category Hebrews says has come to an end.


The argument cannot be answered simply by claiming that believers continue to need forgiveness. Of course they do, but that forgiveness comes through Jesus Christ Himself, the ONE Mediator of the New Testament, whose blood has already obtained remission and whose sacrifice has perfected for ever those who are sanctified. Why, then, should a believer be directed to another sinful man, clothed in priestly authority, to present Christ again as an offering for sin, when that priest himself stands in need of the very forgiveness Christ has already secured? Scripture does not place a succession of earthly sacrificing priests between the redeemed and their Mediator. It directs believers to draw near to God through the blood of Jesus, with hearts sprinkled from an evil conscience and in full assurance of faith.


To make their access dependent upon a further priestly offering is to introduce a sacrificial requirement precisely where Hebrews declares that “there is no more offering for sin” (Hebrews 10:18). The writer has never claimed otherwise. But a continuing need to receive forgiveness is not equivalent to a continuing need for a sin-offering. The New Testament identifies Christ as Mediator precisely because the covenant established through His death remains effective. The believer may continue to receive mercy without the sacrifice itself needing to be presented anew.


If the Mediator administers the blessings of His testament through the efficacy of His one offering, what additional necessity is served by an earthly priest continually presenting Him as a propitiatory sacrifice?


That is the question Hebrews 10:18 places before every doctrine of continuing sin-sacrifice. It is not enough to explain how a different manner of offering avoids a second crucifixion. The doctrine must explain why any further sacrificial presentation is required when the writer declares that remission leaves no more offering for sin.


If the Mass is simply the one historical offering becoming sacramentally accessible to worshippers, the Catholic account maintains that the offering itself has not been multiplied. That is a coherent explanation of what Catholic theology intends to affirm, but it does not by itself establish the teaching from Hebrews. For the chapter's argument is not confined to counting historical deaths; it also concerns the necessity of offering for sin after remission has been accomplished. The question therefore remains whether the repeated liturgical action of offering Christ is required by the New Covenant or whether the believer receives the blessings of that one offering through the Mediator who has already accomplished it.


Hebrews identifies the completed offering as the basis of forgiveness and the continuing priesthood of Christ as belonging to the New Covenant. It does not expressly introduce a second category of continuing earthly propitiatory presentation. That absence becomes significant when the chapter has taken such care to explain why the former order was repeated, why it was superseded, and why no more offering for sin remains.


The Catholic explanation and the question it leaves unanswered

The Roman Catholic Church teaches that the Mass sacramentally makes present Christ's one sacrifice, rather than multiplying the sacrifice of Calvary. The Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§1366–1367, describes the Eucharist as a sacrifice through which the saving effects of Christ's death are applied, and explains that the victim is the same while the manner of offering differs.


The Council of Trent, Session XXII, chapter II, likewise teaches that the Mass is propitiatory, that the same Christ is offered through the ministry of priests (the hierachy), and that it is offered for the living and the dead. It denies that this constitutes another bloody death or diminishes the value of Calvary.

Trent's teaching concerning the Last Supper is especially significant. In Session XXII, chapter I, it argues that Christ instituted a visible sacrifice and commanded the apostles and their successors to offer His body and blood through the words of remembrance. Canon II expressly rejects the view that the words "Do this in commemoration of me" did not institute the apostles as priests with authority to offer His body and blood.


The question must therefore be put directly to the text of Scripture. Where do the recorded words of the Last Supper say that the disciples were appointed to make a continuing propitiatory offering of Christ? Where does Hebrews 10, while explaining the New Covenant's sacrificial foundation, identify such a ministry as necessary? The later doctrinal interpretation may be asserted by a council, but the assertion itself does not demonstrate that the apostolic words contain that command.

The continuing sacrificial character of this teaching is made especially clear by Catholic priests themselves.

St. Alphonsus Liguori, in Dignity and Duties of the Priest, Part II, Instruction I, writes:

"The priest, then, is placed by God in the Church in order to offer sacrifice."

Liguori goes on to identify that sacrifice with the body and blood of the Son of God, distinguishing it from the former animal sacrifices by its value and effects.


The nineteenth-century Redemptorist priest Michael Müller is particularly revealing. In The Blessed Eucharist: Our Greatest Treasure, chapter XV, he argues that the Mass was instituted so that Christianity would possess "what even the Jewish religion possessed, a continual sacrifice." He also describes the Mass as the means by which satisfaction is continually rendered to God.


This reasoning deserves close examination because it appears to preserve as a defining necessity the very characteristic Hebrews uses to distinguish the former sacrificial order from the completed offering of Christ.

Hebrews does not argue that the New Covenant must possess a continual sin-sacrifice because the former covenant possessed one. It argues that the former sacrifices continued because they could not perfect the worshipper, whereas Christ's offering has perfected those who are sanctified. The continual recurrence of offerings is not presented as a feature that must be retained for the sake of religious completeness. It is part of the limitation from which the one offering of Christ delivers the worshipper.


Müller anticipates the objection that continuing to offer Christ at Mass might suggest imperfection in Calvary. He rejects that conclusion by distinguishing the manner of offering and by describing the Mass as a means through which the fruits of the Cross are applied, as though Jesus Christ, the one Mediator of the New Testament, who willingly gave His own life, shed His own blood, and accomplished the sacrifice through which His people are sanctified, were somehow incapable of administering the blessings of His own finished work through His own Holy Spirit without the intervention of an earthly priest who is himself a sinner. Are we seriously to believe that the Son of God can redeem mankind through the offering of His body once for all, yet cannot apply the benefits of that very offering unless another man continually presents Him sacrificially to the Father? What extraordinary power must be attributed to the earthly priest if the living Christ, seated at the right hand of God, cannot dispense the blessings of the covenant established by His own blood without him! Hebrews declares that believers have boldness to enter the holiest through Jesus' blood, with hearts sprinkled from an evil conscience; it does not declare that the one Mediator requires another mediator to make His sacrifice effective. The question is not whether the benefits of Calvary must be applied, but why the living Son of God, who accomplished the sacrifice and mediates the covenant, should require a continuing sacrificial offering by sinful men to apply what He Himself has already secured.


He also explains that sins are not directly and immediately remitted by the Mass itself, but that it is understood to obtain graces, including the grace of repentance.

This distinction must be considered fairly. It prevents us from claiming that Catholic doctrine teaches that every Mass independently completes an otherwise insufficient atonement. But the problem remains: why must the fruits of the Cross be applied through a continuing propitiatory offering, when Christ's mediation already proceeds from the one offering which Hebrews says has accomplished remission?


The application of a completed sacrifice and the offering of a sacrifice are not the same proposition.


If a believer receives forgiveness because Christ has already offered Himself, nothing about that continuing reception requires the sacrificial offering itself to recur. If a Christian repents today, Christ does not need to die today for His blood to remain sufficient. Likewise, it must be demonstrated, not merely asserted, that the application of His blood requires Him to be presented again as a propitiatory offering.


Calling the Mass the same sacrifice does not, by itself, establish that the continued sacrificial presentation is commanded by God. Calling its manner unbloody explains why Catholics do not regard it as another crucifixion, but it does not answer why a recurring sacrificial presentation remains necessary after Hebrews has declared that no more offering for sin remains.

If the recurring ceremony is understood simply as remembrance, thanksgiving, and proclamation of the completed offering, its repetition does not conflict with the principle established in Hebrews 10:2. But if it is understood as a continuing propitiatory offering of Christ, it must be shown why the New Covenant requires a repeated sacrificial act when the writer has expressly connected the completion of cleansing with the cessation of sin-offerings.


This is the distinction upon which the disagreement turns.


Hebrews does not deny that the benefits of Christ's offering continue to be received. It declares that the offering which obtained those benefits has accomplished its purpose. The burden therefore rests upon those who require its continuing sacramental presentation to show where Christ or His apostles commanded such a continuing sin-offering, rather than remembrance of an offering already completed.


There is, however, another part of the Council of Trent's teaching that brings the disagreement into even sharper focus, because it directly concerns the sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving.


In Session XXII, Canon III, Trent rejects the proposition that the Mass is only a sacrifice of praise and thanksgiving, or a commemoration of Calvary without a propitiatory character. It also rejects the proposition that the Mass should not be offered for the living and the dead for sins, punishments, and other necessities. The council is not denying that praise and thanksgiving are acceptable to God, nor that the Mass includes them. It is insisting that the Mass is more than these things: it is a true propitiatory sacrifice.


This distinction matters because the New Testament itself expressly identifies the continuing sacrifices of believers as praise, thanksgiving, doing good, and sharing. The contrast is therefore not between a church that believes Christians should offer sacrifices and one that believes they should offer none. Both accept sacrificial language. The actual disagreement concerns whether a continuing offering of Christ as a victim for sin is required in addition to the spiritual sacrifices that Scripture identifies.


Trent's Canon II also requires close examination. It declares that Christ's words of remembrance established a separate, hierarchical priesthood authorised to offer His body and blood, despite Scripture declaring God's people themselves to be the royal priesthood (1 Peter 2:9). There is no separate sacerdotal hierarchy established among believers in Scripture, nor any privileged class of sacrificing priests appointed to stand between God's people and Jesus Christ, their one Mediator.

The conclusion that the disciples were thereby appointed to offer Christ as a continuing propitiatory victim is not stated in those words. It is the sacrificial interpretation supplied by the council. More importantly, Christ did not appoint Himself to His High Priesthood. His Father appointed Him, and that appointment was confirmed by divine oath. Hebrews 5:4–6 declares that no man takes this honour unto himself, but must be called of God, while Hebrews 7:21 records the Father's oath: “The Lord sware and will not repent, Thou art a priest for ever after the order of Melchisedec.” Where, then, at the Last Supper, did the Father swear any such oath appointing the apostles to Christ's unique and everlasting priesthood, or authorise them to continue offering His Son for sin? He did not. No such divine appointment or oath is recorded. If even the Son did not glorify Himself to be made High Priest, by what scriptural authority does a later council interpret the command to remember His death as the institution of men into a continuing sacrificial priesthood?


This places two teachings directly before the reader. Hebrews 10 declares that the former sacrificial order has been taken away and that the one offering of Christ leaves no further offering for sin. Trent declares that the New Covenant possesses a continuing propitiatory sacrifice offered through priests, and that the words of remembrance establish the authority for that offering. The question is not simply which explanation has a longer history, but which can be demonstrated from the words and logic of the New Testament.


2 Peter 2:3 (KJV):

“And through covetousness shall they with feigned words make merchandise of you: whose judgment now of a long time lingereth not, and their damnation slumbereth not.”

Nor is this resolved by asserting that the Church must possess an altar because the former covenant possessed one. The writer of Hebrews does not establish Christian worship by reproducing every element of the former sanctuary. He identifies Christ's one offering as the accomplishment of God's will and directs believers to draw near through His blood. When he later identifies their continuing sacrifices, he names praise and doing good. The existence of a royal priesthood (all believers) therefore does not, by itself, establish a recurring offering of Christ; it requires us to ask what spiritual sacrifices that priesthood has actually been commanded to present.


The Mediator Gives the Blessings of the New Testament

Having declared that no more offering for sin remains, the writer immediately explains what believers now possess because of Christ's completed work.

"Having therefore, brethren, boldness to enter into the holiest by the blood of Jesus, By a new and living way, which he hath consecrated for us, through the veil, that is to say, his flesh." — Hebrews 10:19–20

The word "therefore" is essential. The invitation to enter into the holiest follows directly from the conclusion that Christ's one sacrifice has accomplished remission and that no further offering for sin remains.

The believer's confidence is grounded in the blood of Jesus. The way into God's presence has been consecrated through His flesh, and the writer describes that way as new and living.

What follows is remarkable when compared with the former sacrificial order. The worshipper is not instructed to seek another victim or to wait until Christ has been sacrificially presented again. He is instructed to approach God because the sacrifice necessary for that access has already been accomplished.


Verse 21 acknowledges the continuing reality of Christ's priesthood, describing Him as the great high priest over the house of God. The writer does not abolish Christ's priesthood when he declares His sacrifice complete. He distinguishes the enduring priestly ministry of the living Son from the repeated sin-offerings associated with the former order.

This distinction also explains why the title Mediator of the New Testament is so important. A mediator acts in relation to the covenant and its promised benefits. Hebrews 9:15 states:

"And for this cause he is the mediator of the new testament, that by means of death, for the redemption of the transgressions that were under the first testament, they which are called might receive the promise of eternal inheritance."

The verse connects three things: Christ is the Mediator (not a priest); His death accomplishes redemption; and those who are called receive the promised inheritance.

The order is essential. The death is not repeatedly accomplished whenever another person receives the inheritance. It has already occurred, and the Mediator of the New Testament is the One through whom the promise stands.


Hebrews 9:16–17 then explains the necessity of the Testator's death:

"For where a testament is, there must also of necessity be the death of the testator. For a testament is of force after men are dead: otherwise it is of no strength at all while the testator liveth."

The point is that the testament obtains its force through the required death. The writer does not say that its authority must be ceremonially re-established whenever another beneficiary receives what has been promised.


This brings us to the exact distinction that must govern the question of the Mass. If the covenant has been established through Christ's death, and if He is the living Mediator of that covenant, the continuing reception of its blessings does not mean that the covenant-establishing sacrifice remains to be offered. Its benefits continue because its foundation remains valid.

The covenant's benefits are not detached from Christ. They come through Him, through the indwelling Holy Spirit, with whom believers are sealed upon believing the gospel of their salvation (Ephesians 1:13–14). It is through this same Spirit that God's law is written upon their hearts, that they are brought into fellowship with the Father through His Son, and that the blessings of the New Testament are received by faith, without requiring the intervention of an earthly sacrificing priest.The Christian does not obtain forgiveness independently of the Mediator, nor does he possess a right to grace apart from His blood. But neither does the continuing ministry of the Mediator imply that His body must continually be presented as a propitiatory victim.


A doctrine may teach that God uses particular means to communicate grace. The mere existence of such means is not the issue. The question is whether Scripture establishes a continuing sacrificial offering of Christ as one of those means, when Hebrews 10 has made the completion of His sin-offering the very reason believers may approach God.

This is why it is insufficient simply to answer that the Mass applies the fruits of Calvary. If the Mediator of the New Testament already administers the blessings flowing from His completed death, why must the application of those blessings be understood as another act of offering Christ? Does the New Covenant promise require that action, or is it an additional sacrificial requirement imposed upon the covenant after its establishment?


The words of Hebrews 10:19–22 provide a direct answer concerning access to God. Believers have boldness through the blood of Jesus, and they are called to draw near with full assurance of faith.

Then comes the instruction:

"Let us draw near with a true heart in full assurance of faith, having our hearts sprinkled from an evil conscience, and our bodies washed with pure water." — Hebrews 10:22

The relationship with verse 2 is unmistakable. Earlier, the inability of the former sacrifices to purge the conscience explained why they continued. Now the believer is described as having a heart sprinkled from an evil conscience and is invited to approach God in full assurance of faith.

The very cleansing whose absence characterised the former order is now associated with the believer's access to God through Christ.


This is why the New Covenant cannot be reduced to the introduction of a new ceremony of recurring sin-sacrifice. The writer has moved from an order in which the worshipper repeatedly approached through sacrifices that could not perfect the conscience to one in which the believer is invited to draw near through the blood of Jesus.


Hebrews 8:10–12 explains the inward character of this covenant more fully. God promises to place His laws within His people, to be their God, and to remember their sins and iniquities no more. The believer's relationship with God is therefore founded upon forgiveness and inward obedience, rather than upon the continuing liability that made repeated sin-offerings necessary.

The connection with Romans 6:3–6 is also important. Paul explains that believers are baptised into Christ's death and buried with Him through baptism, so that they should walk in newness of life. The old man is crucified with Him, and the purpose is that the believer should no longer serve sin.

Baptism identifies the believer with Christ's accomplished death. It does not establish a succession of new sacrificial deaths. The believer receives the gospel, is baptised into Christ's death, and is called to live according to the new life that follows. His subsequent growth in holiness does not require Christ to undergo another offering.


Nor does it follow that a Christian who sins after baptism has somehow caused the New Covenant sacrifice to become inadequate. Deliberate Sin remains serious, repentance remains necessary, and the believer must continually resist the temptation to return to disobedience. But the remedy is not to make Christ's offering complete again. It is to return in repentance and faith to the God whose mercy has been established through that offering.


This is precisely why Hebrews 10:23–25 directs believers toward perseverance, love, and good works. They are told to hold fast their profession without wavering, encourage one another, and continue assembling together.

The writer knows that the Christian life involves struggle. He knows that believers will need exhortation and patience. Nevertheless, after declaring that there is no more offering for sin, he does not establish another sacrificial system for their continuing moral weakness.

He tells them to live in the confidence that Christ's blood has opened the way to God.

The kind of sacrifice God now requires from His people is expressly identified later in the epistle:

"By him therefore let us offer the sacrifice of praise to God continually, that is, the fruit of our lips giving thanks to his name. But to do good and to communicate forget not: for with such sacrifices God is well pleased." — Hebrews 13:15–16

These words provide an important contrast with Hebrews 10:5–10.

Earlier, the writer explained that God had no pleasure in the former sacrifices as the final means of dealing with sin. Here he identifies the sacrifices with which God is well pleased: praise, thanksgiving, doing good, and sharing with others.

Notice especially the word "continually." Christian worship has not ceased because Christ's sin-offering has been accomplished. Believers are still called to offer sacrifices continually, but the sacrifices expressly described are not continuing propitiatory presentations of Christ.

They are the grateful and obedient responses of people whose reconciliation with God rests upon His completed work.


This does not mean that praise or good deeds earn atonement. If they could accomplish the removal of sin, Christ's sacrifice would not have been necessary. Rather, these acts express the life made possible through His offering. The believer praises God because mercy has been received, gives thanks because forgiveness has been granted, and does good because God's law is being written upon the heart.


The Lord's supper likewise belongs to the continuing remembrance and proclamation of Christ's death. Its repeated observance need not imply that the sacrifice remembered is itself being repeated. A completed offering remains worthy of remembrance precisely because its accomplishment endures.

The contrast is therefore substantial. The former sacrifices returned continually because they could not perfect the worshipper. Christ's offering has accomplished the necessary cleansing. The worshipper now draws near through His blood and offers the sacrifices of thanksgiving, praise, obedience, and generosity with which God is well pleased.


The royal priesthood and the sacrifices that must continue

The argument becomes even stronger when Hebrews 13 is read alongside the apostle Peter's description of those who belong to Christ.

Peter writes:

"Ye also, as lively stones, are built up a spiritual house, an holy priesthood, to offer up spiritual sacrifices, acceptable to God by Jesus Christ." — 1 Peter 2:5

He then declares:

"But ye are a chosen generation, a royal priesthood, an holy nation, a peculiar people; that ye should shew forth the praises of him who hath called you out of darkness into his marvellous light." — 1 Peter 2:9

These verses are essential because they identify both the priesthood and the nature of its offering. ALL Believers are described as living stones forming a spiritual house, a holy priesthood whose sacrifices are acceptable to God through Jesus Christ. The purpose of this royal priesthood includes showing forth the praises of the One who has called them out of darkness into His marvellous light.


Peter does not describe a priesthood whose members must repeatedly offer Christ as a propitiatory victim. He describes a people who have been brought near to God and who therefore offer spiritual sacrifices acceptable through Him.

Nor does this priesthood depend upon the worshipper having achieved personal perfection through his own conduct. Its offerings are acceptable "by Jesus Christ." The believer's praise, thanksgiving, obedience, and generosity do not replace His sacrifice; they depend upon it. Christ's completed work is the reason those offerings may now be received by God.


This relationship is fundamental. The sacrificial offering through which sin is removed belongs to Christ. The spiritual sacrifices offered by believers follow that accomplishment and express the life made possible through it. To confuse the two is to confuse the sacrifice that reconciles with the sacrifices of those who have been reconciled.


The title royal priesthood is therefore not an empty honour. It establishes that believers have a real priestly calling, but Scripture defines the character of that calling. They are to proclaim God's praises, offer thanksgiving, do good, share their possessions, and live in holiness. These are not merely optional alternatives to an otherwise necessary propitiatory offering. They are the positive forms of sacrifice expressly named in the apostolic teaching.

Paul's words in Romans 12:1 are consistent with this pattern:

"I beseech you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God, that ye present your bodies a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable unto God, which is your reasonable service."

The believer presents himself as a living sacrifice in response to the mercies of God. This does not mean that his body becomes another victim for the atonement of sin. It means that his life is consecrated to God in grateful obedience because the mercy upon which his reconciliation depends has already been received.


The distinction can now be expressed with greater clarity. The New Covenant does not abolish sacrificial worship in every sense. It abolishes the former necessity of repeated offerings for sin, because Christ has accomplished the atonement toward which they pointed. The continuing sacrifices belong to the royal priesthood of believers, and Scripture identifies their character as spiritual rather than as a recurring propitiatory offering of the Son.


This is precisely why Hebrews 13:15–16 must be read in connection with Hebrews 10:18. The writer who declares that no more offering for sin remains does not subsequently instruct the church to continue offering Christ for sin. Instead, he instructs believers to offer praise continually and not to neglect doing good and sharing. The continuity is not in recurring atonement, but in worship proceeding from an accomplished atonement.


This also clarifies the dispute with the Council of Trent. Canon III does not condemn praise or thanksgiving. It condemns the view that the Mass is only praise, thanksgiving, or commemoration rather than also a propitiatory sacrifice. The scriptural question is therefore whether that additional propitiatory character is required by the New Covenant. Hebrews expressly identifies the one offering for sin as complete, while the apostles identify the continuing sacrifices of believers as praise, thanksgiving, holy living, and doing good.


If those are the sacrifices God expressly tells His people to continue offering, where is the corresponding command that His Son must continue being presented as a propitiatory victim? The question is not answered merely by observing that Christians are priests, because Peter has already told us what kind of sacrifices this royal priesthood offers. Nor is it answered by observing that Christians continue to sin, because the living Mediator administers the blessings of the testament established through His completed death.

This is the positive strength of the New Covenant pattern. It does not leave the worshipper spiritually inactive after Christ has finished the sacrificial work. It calls the redeemed person into a life of constant praise, thanksgiving, holiness, compassion, and obedience. Those spiritual sacrifices do not compete with Christ's sacrifice or suggest that His offering was incomplete. They bear witness to its efficacy by showing the life that flows from it.


The difference between the former and the new order is therefore not that God once desired sacrifice and now desires no worship. It is that the sacrifice required for the remission of sin has been accomplished through His Son, and the sacrifices now offered by His people are the grateful responses of those whose consciences have been cleansed.

The royal priesthood does not continually offer Christ in order to obtain the cleansing that His sacrifice was meant to accomplish. It offers praise, thanksgiving, obedience, and good works because the cleansing has been accomplished through Him.


The Warning Against Trampling the Son of God Underfoot

The argument of Hebrews 10 becomes particularly solemn when the writer turns from the privileges of the New Covenant to the consequences of rejecting the truth upon which those privileges rest.

"For if we sin wilfully after that we have received the knowledge of the truth, there remaineth no more sacrifice for sins." — Hebrews 10:26

The connection with verse 18 is immediate and important. The writer has already declared that where remission exists there is no more offering for sin. He now warns that those who deliberately turn away from the truth cannot look elsewhere for another sacrifice.

The context concerns the grave rejection of the truth received, particularly the sacrifice and covenant through which forgiveness has been obtained.


Christ has accomplished what those sacrifices could not, and the first has been taken away. If the truth concerning His offering is repudiated, there is no other sin-offering waiting to accomplish what He has already accomplished.

This explains the fearful language that follows:

"But a certain fearful looking for of judgment and fiery indignation, which shall devour the adversaries." — Hebrews 10:27

The contrast is between confidence in the accomplished work of Christ and the terrifying condition of rejecting the only sacrifice through which remission has been secured.

The writer then recalls the seriousness of despising the law of Moses, before asking how much greater the offence must be when the Son of God and the blood of His covenant are rejected.

"Of how much sorer punishment, suppose ye, shall he be thought worthy, who hath trodden under foot the Son of God, and hath counted the blood of the covenant, wherewith he was sanctified, an unholy thing, and hath done despite unto the Spirit of grace?" — Hebrews 10:29

This warning demands close examination because every part of it relates to the covenant and sacrifice already discussed.


The three charges describe a grave rejection of the Son, His covenant blood, and the Spirit of grace. They belong to the writer's warning about deliberate apostasy, and none should be lifted from that setting and treated as a direct description of a later religious ceremony. Yet the chapter's preceding argument gives these words considerable significance when any doctrine concerning Christ's continuing sacrificial offering is examined.


Trampling the Son of God underfoot

The image is one of deliberate contempt. To trample something underfoot is to treat it as worthless or deserving of rejection. Applied to the Son of God, the accusation describes an extraordinary offence against the One whose blood has established the New Covenant.

The seriousness of this act becomes clear when it is connected with the preceding verses.


Christ is the Son who came to fulfil the Father's will. His body was prepared for the offering through which believers are sanctified. By one offering He perfected for ever those who are sanctified, and through His blood the way into God's presence has been opened.

To reject Him after receiving the knowledge of this truth is therefore not simply to reject one religious custom among many. It is to reject the One through whom the only sufficient sacrifice has been made.


This is why verse 26 declares that no more sacrifice for sins remains. The warning is not merely that apostasy is morally wrong. It is that there is no alternative sacrificial remedy outside the Son whose offering has accomplished remission.

The writer's reasoning is therefore consistent from the beginning of the chapter. The former sacrifices could not perfect the worshipper. Christ's offering accomplished the necessary perfection. The former order has been taken away, and no other sacrifice remains for those who reject the truth.

The offence of trampling the Son of God underfoot concerns the repudiation of that decisive and sufficient work.


Now consider why a continuing sacrificial system raises such a serious question in the light of this warning. If a believer is taught to depend upon the continuing presentation of Christ as a sin-offering, despite the declaration that His one offering has perfected those who are sanctified, the danger is that confidence may shift from the sufficiency of the accomplished work to the necessity of a recurring sacrificial act.


That does not mean that every believer participating in such a ceremony consciously despises Christ. A Catholic may sincerely understand the Mass as honouring the Cross and receiving its benefits. But doctrinal sincerity and the scriptural correctness of a practice are separate questions. If a system actually required believers to treat the one offering as inadequate without further sacrificial presentation, its principle would stand in direct opposition to the finality Hebrews establishes.

The grave question is whether a sacrificial system that continually presents the Son for sin honours the completed offering by which He perfected the worshipper, or whether it obscures that completion by making sacrificial presentation appear continually necessary.


That is the connection to trampling underfoot. The verse explicitly concerns rejecting Christ, not merely holding an incorrect explanation of a sacrament. Nevertheless, if a doctrine undermines confidence in the very offering through which the covenant was established, its implications deserve examination under the chapter's warning against repudiating the Son and His sacrifice.


We should examine the distinction even more closely. A person may affirm verbally that Christ's sacrifice was sufficient while nevertheless being taught to approach God through a recurring sacrificial presentation that appears indispensable to obtaining forgiveness. The problem is not that such a person necessarily intends to insult Christ. It is that the doctrine may direct the conscience toward an ongoing sacrificial requirement rather than toward the completed offering and the living Mediator through whom its blessings are received.


That possibility matters because Hebrews has not merely declared the sacrifice complete; it has commanded the believer to approach God in full assurance of faith. The worshipper who remains convinced that another propitiatory presentation must take place before the covenant's blessings can reach him may struggle to possess the very confidence the writer seeks to establish. The question is whether the system strengthens that confidence by directing him to Christ's one offering, or weakens it by placing another sacrificial requirement between the believer and the assurance promised through His blood.


If the latter were established, the objection would be more serious than a dispute over ceremony. It would concern the believer's understanding of the work of the Son Himself. A teaching that effectively returns the conscience to a continuing dependence upon sin-offerings would obscure the accomplishment upon which Hebrews makes the New Covenant rest.


Counting the covenant blood an unholy thing

The second charge is even more closely connected with the argument concerning cleansing.

The blood described in verse 29 is the blood of the covenant, the blood through which sanctification is attributed to the person under discussion. The word translated "unholy" conveys the sense of treating something as common or profane, rather than recognising its sacred character.

The gravity of the offence lies in what that blood has accomplished. It is not the blood of animals that could never take away sins. It is the blood of the Son whose one offering has established the New Covenant and brought the sacrificial work to completion.

To count that blood unholy is therefore to reject its sacred significance and the covenant standing secured through it.


Now consider the doctrinal implications.


If Christ's blood is the blood through which the believer is sanctified, and if His one offering has perfected for ever those who are sanctified, what follows when His blood is treated as though the work of remission remains dependent upon recurring sacrificial offerings?

We must distinguish the explicit warning from its application. Verse 29 does not directly identify the Mass, nor does it establish that every Catholic who participates in it knowingly rejects Christ. Catholic doctrine explicitly affirms the sufficiency and holiness of Calvary, and it describes the Mass as the presentation and application of that one sacrifice rather than as a replacement for it.


Nevertheless, the theological question remains grave. If the continuing presentation of Christ as a sin-offering is taught to be necessary because the original sacrifice has not accomplished the required remission, that claim would directly contradict the perfection and finality Hebrews attributes to His blood.


The Catholic account attempts to avoid this consequence by distinguishing the sacrifice's accomplishment from the application of its fruits. That distinction must be considered fairly. Yet it also requires a further explanation: why must those fruits be applied by a continuing sacrificial presentation of Christ, when Hebrews directs the believer to draw near through the blood already shed?

The danger being investigated is not the mere repetition of a ceremony. It is the possibility of returning to a principle of continuing sin-sacrifice after God has declared that the one offering of His Son has accomplished remission.

The blood of Christ is not made more sufficient by being offered in another manner. Neither does its value increase through repeated presentations. If His one offering has accomplished the work, then the continuing benefit of that blood must be distinguished from the continuing sacrificial offering of the victim.


The Mediator of the New Testament is especially important here. The covenant blood is holy because it is the blood through which the promised inheritance has been secured. Christ is the ONE Mediator through whom the covenant's blessings are received. His mediation does not diminish the sacredness of that blood; it depends upon its accomplished efficacy.

Consequently, the believer need not regard the blood as something whose saving value is exhausted between one act of worship and the next. It is the blood of the covenant, offered through the Son's obedient death and sufficient to establish the remission God promises. When the believer repents, he does not require another sacrificial death, and Hebrews gives no instruction that a new sacrificial presentation must be supplied before the Mediator can administer the blessing.


A continuing system of propitiatory offerings therefore raises a question more serious than whether the ceremony is physically identical to Calvary. Why is the offering itself continually presented for sin if the blood of the covenant has already accomplished remission, and the living Mediator remains the source of its blessings?

To answer that the ceremony makes the sacrifice present is not yet to explain why the ceremony must have the character of a sin-offering. The completed sacrifice can remain effective, be remembered, be proclaimed, and be the foundation of forgiveness without the biblical conclusion that it must continually be offered.


At the beginning of the chapter, the worshipper's continuing consciousness of sin is evidence that the former offerings have not brought the necessary cleansing. Later, the writer describes hearts sprinkled from an evil conscience and invites the believers to draw near in full assurance of faith. The blood of the covenant is therefore not merely an object of religious contemplation; its efficacy is meant to transform the worshipper's standing before God.


If a system of recurring propitiatory offerings leaves the believer continually dependent upon another sacrificial presentation before he can rest in that promise, the result demands examination. Does the worshipper understand that the blood of Christ has already accomplished the remission upon which he may approach God, or does his conscience remain attached to the idea that a further sin-offering must be presented? The first accords with the writer's invitation to draw near through the completed work; the second risks restoring the sacrificial dependence that the chapter explains Christ came to end.


That is why the holiness of the covenant blood cannot be separated from its sufficiency. Its sacred character belongs to what God has accomplished through it. A doctrine that treated this blood as inadequate without continuing offerings would be difficult to reconcile with the reverence Hebrews requires. Whether a particular ceremony actually does so must be established from its teaching, but the principle is sufficiently serious that the question cannot be dismissed.


Doing despite unto the Spirit of grace

The third accusation has an important relationship with verse 15.

Earlier in the chapter, the writer declared:

"Whereof the Holy Ghost also is a witness to us." — Hebrews 10:15

The testimony that follows concerns the New Covenant promise: God's laws written in the heart and sins remembered no more.

The Holy Spirit is therefore presented as a witness to the covenant established through Christ. The warning in verse 29 concerns doing despite unto the Spirit of grace, an offence against the divine grace made known through that covenant.

The relationship should not be overstated into a claim that every disagreement concerning the Eucharist constitutes this sin. The immediate warning concerns the rejection of Christ and His covenant. But the passage does establish the seriousness of contradicting or repudiating the truth to which the Spirit bears witness.


The Spirit testifies to a covenant in which sins are remembered no more. The writer concludes that where remission exists there is no more offering for sin. The warning then describes the fearful condition of one who rejects the Son, dishonours the covenant blood, and insults the Spirit of grace.

These are not isolated offences. Together they describe the repudiation of the New Covenant and the salvation established through Christ.


This is why the warning must not be reduced to a general statement that religious error is dangerous. Its severity arises from the identity of the Son, the holiness of His blood, and the impossibility of replacing the sacrifice through which remission has been obtained.

The writer continues:

"For we know him that hath said, Vengeance belongeth unto me, I will recompense, saith the Lord. And again, The Lord shall judge his people. It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God." — Hebrews 10:30–31

The argument has now moved from the insufficiency of the former sacrifices to the seriousness of rejecting the one sacrifice that has accomplished God's will.

There is no suggestion that a worshipper who abandons confidence in Christ can return to another sacrificial order and obtain the same cleansing. The former sacrifices have been taken away, and the Son's offering is the sufficient sacrifice upon which the New Covenant rests.


The warning therefore gives the entire discussion of sacrifice its full seriousness. The question is not merely which ceremony a Christian prefers. It is whether the worshipper places confidence in the covenant established through the offering of Christ, or returns to a dependence upon sacrificial requirements that have not been established by the words of the New Covenant.

Verse 29 must not be used to pronounce judgment upon individuals whose hearts and understanding are known to God. But neither should its warning be ignored when examining teachings that concern the offering of His Son.


The holiness, sufficiency, and finality of Christ's blood are not minor matters. They stand at the centre of the covenant through which believers have been sanctified.

The challenge may therefore be stated in its strongest defensible form. Hebrews 10:29 explicitly condemns those who deliberately reject the Son and profane His covenant blood. It does not directly condemn a later sacramental ceremony by name. Nevertheless, the chapter supplies a principle by which such a ceremony must be tested: does it lead the worshipper to rest in the once-for-all offering by which the conscience is purged, or does it establish a continuing dependence upon sacrificial presentation that the chapter says has been brought to an end?


If the latter were demonstrated, the difficulty would not be merely that the ceremony lacks an explicit command. It would be that the doctrine risks returning the believer to the very principle of repeated sin-sacrifice from which the New Covenant delivers him. That is a grave concern in a chapter which treats departure from confidence in Christ's covenant blood as a matter of judgment.

The three accusations in verse 29 must therefore be held together with the positive teaching that precedes them. The Son has offered Himself once; His blood has established the covenant; the Spirit witnesses to God's promise of remission. To reject the Son is to reject the One who accomplished the offering. To count His blood unholy is to treat the means of sanctification with contempt. To insult the Spirit of grace is to reject the divine witness to the covenant's promise.


The challenge to a continuing propitiatory system is not that every participant intends these offences, but whether the system itself directs the conscience away from the accomplished offering and back toward a dependence upon recurring sacrifice. If it does, the doctrinal danger is inseparable from the very truths Hebrews warns believers not to abandon.

There is no stronger reason to examine a teaching carefully than the possibility that it may obscure the covenant blessings Christ came to secure. If a worshipper believes that the Son's offering has already perfected those who are sanctified, the proper response is confidence in His blood, repentance, perseverance, and the spiritual sacrifices of the royal priesthood. If the same worshipper is taught that a propitiatory offering of Christ must nevertheless continue, the distinction between the completed work and the continuing sacrificial requirement must be demonstrated from Scripture.

The warning of Hebrews 10:29 gives that question its appropriate gravity without authorising us to pronounce judgment upon every individual who holds the doctrine.


Remember the Faith You Once Had, Not the Sacrifices That Could Never Perfect You

After this fearful warning, the writer changes his tone and calls the believers to remember their former endurance:

"But call to remembrance the former days, in which, after ye were illuminated, ye endured a great fight of afflictions." — Hebrews 10:32

This instruction becomes particularly meaningful when compared with verse 3.

At the beginning of the chapter, the recurring sacrifices brought sins to remembrance again every year. Their repetition belonged to a system that could never perfect the worshipper.

Now, after declaring that Christ has offered one sacrifice, that sins are remembered no more, and that no further offering for sin remains, the writer directs believers toward a different object of remembrance.

They are to remember the days when they first received the light and endured suffering because of their faith.


They are not instructed to recall their sins through another recurring sacrificial ceremony. They are instructed to remember the confidence and endurance they demonstrated after receiving the truth.

Verses 33–34 describe the afflictions they had endured. They had suffered reproach, stood alongside others who were persecuted, shown compassion to those in bonds, and accepted the spoiling of their goods because they knew they possessed a better and enduring inheritance.

Their former conduct testified to the faith by which they had already endured suffering. The writer now calls them to remember that confidence and continue in it.

Verse 35 declares:

"Cast not away therefore your confidence, which hath great recompence of reward." — Hebrews 10:35

Notice the object of the exhortation. The believers are not told to seek security by returning to repeated sacrificial offerings. They are commanded to preserve their confidence.

This confidence has already been explained in verses 19–22. It is the boldness to enter the holiest through the blood of Jesus, with hearts sprinkled from an evil conscience.

The writer therefore returns the believer to the very result of Christ's offering. The conscience has been cleansed, access to God has been opened, and the Christian is called to remain faithful rather than abandon the confidence established through His blood.

Verse 36 continues:

"For ye have need of patience, that, after ye have done the will of God, ye might receive the promise." — Hebrews 10:36

The reference to God's will recalls the earlier declaration of the Son: "Lo, I come to do thy will, O God."

Christ came to accomplish the Father's redemptive purpose through His own offering. The believer, having received the knowledge of that work, is now called to do God's will through faithful endurance.

These are not equivalent sacrifices. Christ's obedience accomplished the offering through which the believer is sanctified. The believer's obedience proceeds from faith in that offering. But the connection is important because the New Covenant does not produce a people who remain indifferent to God's commandments. It produces people in whose hearts His law is written, who are then called to persevere in doing His will.

Verse 37 directs their attention toward the coming of Christ, and verse 38 establishes the principle upon which their continuing life must rest:

"Now the just shall live by faith: but if any man draw back, my soul shall have no pleasure in him." — Hebrews 10:38

God has established His will through the offering of His Son. He has taken away the former sacrificial order and established the covenant through which sins are remembered no more. Those who have received this truth are called to continue in faith, not to draw back from the confidence obtained through Christ.


The writer does not define persevering faith as repeated dependence upon an earthly presentation of Christ as a sin-offering. He has already declared that the one offering has accomplished remission and that no further offering for sin remains. His exhortation concerns the believer's continuing trust in that work and faithful obedience to God.

This is where the Mediator of the New Testament again becomes relevant. The believer does not persevere by imagining that he must repeatedly obtain a new sacrificial foundation for his relationship with God. He perseveres because the covenant rests upon the death already accomplished and the Son who continues to mediate its blessings.


The believer's confidence is not that his conscience will never again require correction, but that the covenant established through Christ's blood remains the foundation upon which he may repent (to God, through Christ, not another sinner) and draw near to God. It is not that his obedience will be perfect, but that the Son's offering is sufficient and that he must therefore continue in faithful obedience. The life of faith is a continuing response to a completed redemption, not a continuing attempt to complete redemption by returning to sin-sacrifice.

The final verse brings the entire chapter to its conclusion:

"But we are not of them who draw back unto perdition; but of them that believe to the saving of the soul." — Hebrews 10:39

The last contrast is not between two sacrificial ceremonies, but between drawing back and believing.

The chapter does not end by commanding another sin-offering. It ends by declaring that the righteous shall live by faith and that those who persevere in believing are not among those who draw back unto perdition.


God did not send His Son merely to provide a more valuable victim for an endless succession of sin-offerings. According to Hebrews, the Son came to fulfil His will through the offering of His own body once for all. The first was taken away so that the second could be established.

And the chapter's closing appeal is entirely consistent with that accomplishment:

"Now the just shall live by faith."

Not by repeatedly seeking another sin-offering, but by believing in the One whose offering has opened the way to God, persevering in that confidence, and living in the holiness, thanksgiving, praise, and good works that follow from His completed sacrifice.


If Christ's one offering has already purged the conscience, perfected those who are sanctified, established the New Testament through His blood, and left no more offering for sin, are people being prevented from resting in that promised cleansing by a system that continually directs them back to a propitiatory offering? And if they are taught to depend upon the repeated sacrificial presentation of the very Son whose one offering God has declared sufficient, does such a system not risk trampling underfoot the sacrifice that brought the former order to an end, treating the covenant blood as though its work remained unfinished, and drawing the worshipper away from the faith and confidence Hebrews commands him to hold fast?


If we are told that “we have this treasure in earthen vessels” (2 Corinthians 4:7), and Daniel declares that “they shall mingle themselves with the seed of men” (Daniel 2:43), should we not examine more deeply what Scripture reveals about the struggle over the children of God? From the beginning, God declared enmity between the seed of the serpent and the seed of the woman (Genesis 3:15), while Isaiah speaks of “children of transgression, a seed of falsehood” (Isaiah 57:4). Peter warns that through covetousness false teachers would And through covetousness shall they with feigned words make merchandise of you (2 Peter 2:3), and Hosea records the extraordinary accusation that “they have begotten strange children” (Hosea 5:7). Christ Himself condemned certain religious leaders as “serpents” and a “generation of vipers” (Matthew 23:33), accusing them of shutting up the kingdom of heaven against men, neither entering themselves nor allowing those who were entering to go in (Matthew 23:13). When these passages are considered alongside Christ's solemn warning, “hold that fast which thou hast, that no man take thy crown” (Revelation 3:11), an unsettling question emerges: could the deception, corruption, exploitation, and attempted mingling of the holy seed represent a wider struggle to prevent God's children from remaining faithful and receiving the crown promised to them? If Scripture distinguishes between two seeds, speaks of strange children, warns that "they" will make merchandise of others through feigned words, and exposes religious leaders who actively obstruct entrance into the kingdom, should we not continue examining who the serpent's seed truly represents, who the mysterious “they” in Daniel might be, and whether these passages reveal a connected attempt to corrupt the people of God and hinder their inheritance? The question deserves careful investigation, with Scripture itself establishing whether these different passages describe the same adversaries or distinct forms of opposition.


Why does Scripture warn of a beast ascending from the bottomless pit, one that “was, and is not, and yet is” (Revelation 17:8), suggesting a mysterious return? Why would the sons of God, already redeemed through Jesus Christ, require another mediator between themselves and their Redeemer? Why such covetousness, unless “they” envy an inheritance that does not belong to them? Could “they” be the “seed of transgression” (Isaiah 57:4), seeking to corrupt the holy seed and steal the crown promised to the faithful? And could the succession of beast kingdoms, from Babylon and the prophetic fall of Lucifer to the final kingdom of the beast, reveal an ancient rebellion persisting through earthly powers until Christ returns to destroy them once for all? Are we witnessing throughout Scripture a continuing struggle over God's inheritance, in which the enemy seeks not merely earthly dominion, but to prevent the sons of God from entering the kingdom and receiving their crowns?


Sources and primary texts

Scripture: All biblical quotations are from the King James Version, principally Hebrews 10:1–39, with supporting references to Hebrews 8:10–12; Hebrews 9:15–17; Hebrews 13:15–16; Romans 6:3–6; Romans 12:1; 1 Peter 2:5, 9; Luke 22:19; and 1 Corinthians 11:24–26.

Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§1362–1367 and 1414, official Vatican edition. These sections establish the Catholic teaching that the Eucharist makes present Christ's one sacrifice and applies its fruits, while describing the offering as sacrificial and propitiatory. Read the official text.

Council of Trent, Session XXII, 17 September 1562, chapters I–II and canons I–IV, Doctrine on the Sacrifice of the Mass. These passages explain the council's claim that Christ instituted a continuing visible sacrifice at the Last Supper, its distinction between Calvary and the unbloody offering of the Mass, and its doctrine that the Mass is propitiatory. Canon II concerns the claimed priestly commission in the words of remembrance; Canon III concerns the claim that the Mass is more than praise, thanksgiving, and commemoration; Canon IV rejects the accusation that the Mass derogates from the sacrifice of Calvary. Read the historical decrees.

St. Alphonsus Maria de Liguori, Dignity and Duties of the Priest; or, Selva, Part II, Instruction I, "The Celebration of Mass," edited by Rev. Eugene Grimm, English edition, Benziger Brothers, 1889, pp. 208–209. The quotation concerning the priest's office appears at the beginning of this instruction. Read the historical edition.

Rev. Michael Müller, C.Ss.R., The Blessed Eucharist: Our Greatest Treasure, chapter XV, "The Most Holy Sacrifice of the Mass." The statements concerning continual sacrifice, the manner of offering, the necessity of sacramental application, and the alleged preservation of a continual sacrifice corresponding to the former covenant appear in his explanation and defence of the Mass's propitiatory character. Read chapter XV.

Greek word reference: ἀνάμνησις (anamnēsis), meaning remembrance or memorial, as used in Hebrews 10:3, Luke 22:19, and 1 Corinthians 11:24–25. Greek New Testament lexical reference.

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
"Captured: A supernatural moment frozen in time as a dove gracefully joins the sun in a celestial dance. Witness the ethereal

Free ebook

My own story that reveals the reality of our existence, taking us from the ordinary to the extraordinary. Overcoming the darkness that binds our souls to the material world and exploring the spirit world beyond the veil.

Thank you for subscribing!

© 2023 Rebuild Spirit. All rights reserved.

bottom of page