THE CONSECRATED WAY AND THE PRIESTHOOD ROME CLAIMS

If Christ consecrated the way into the holiest through His own flesh, and the apostles were among the brethren for whom that way was opened, what sacrificial priesthood could they possibly have transmitted to the bishops of Rome?

The Roman Catholic Church claims to possess a sacrificial priesthood descending from the apostles, through which ordained men are authorised to offer the body and blood of Jesus Christ to God. Its bishops claim succession to an authority originally bestowed upon those whom Christ appointed, and its priests are said to receive through ordination a permanent sacramental character enabling them to act in the person of Christ. Yet before accepting any claim of priestly succession, we must investigate something far more fundamental than the historical continuity of the Roman episcopate. We must establish whether Christ ever consecrated His apostles into the particular sacrificial priesthood which Rome claims to have inherited.
There can be no succession to an office that was never instituted, and no transmission of a sacrificial authority that was never bestowed upon its supposed first holders. A succession of bishops may demonstrate the continuation of ecclesiastical leadership, but the existence of bishops does not prove that their predecessors possessed the power to offer Christ sacrificially. To establish that proposition, Rome must demonstrate that Christ gave such authority to the apostles, not merely that the apostles appointed others to exercise ministries within the Church.
The difficulty is that the Epistle to the Hebrews identifies an entirely different consecration at the centre of Christ's redemptive work. What Christ consecrated was the way into the holiest, through His own flesh, so that the brethren might enter by His blood. The apostles were not the object of that consecrating act. They were among those for whom the way was opened. Their calling as apostles gave them a particular responsibility towards the brethren, but their access to God rested upon the same blood by which all the redeemed are admitted.
We must therefore examine not simply what the apostles were called to do upon earth, but what Christ actually consecrated, what His consecration accomplished, and what Scripture reveals concerning the ultimate priestly standing of the redeemed in His Kingdom. When these matters are considered together, the distinction between serving Christ and offering Christ becomes impossible to ignore.
THE WAY WAS CONSECRATED — NOT THE APOSTLES
Hebrews 10:10–22 must be read as one connected argument, because its conclusion concerning the consecrated way depends upon everything the writer has already established concerning the sufficiency of Christ's sacrifice.
The chapter first identifies the offering through which sanctification is accomplished:
Hebrews 10:10:
"By the which will we are sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all."
The body offered is Christ's own body, and the sanctification of His people proceeds from that offering. The writer does not describe a sacrifice which provides only partial sanctification until an additional order of earthly priests begins administering its benefits through sacrificial offerings. He describes the accomplishment of God's will through Christ's self-offering, an event whose sufficiency is emphasised by the words once for all.
Verse 11 then contrasts Christ with the priests of the former arrangement, whose daily ministry involved standing and repeatedly offering sacrifices which could never take away sins. Christ, however, having offered His one sacrifice, sat down at the right hand of God. The contrast concerns more than the number of sacrifices. It concerns the difference between an unfinished sacrificial ministry and the completed offering through which Christ accomplished what the former sacrifices could not.
The writer brings this contrast to its decisive conclusion in verse 14:
"For by one offering he hath perfected for ever them that are sanctified."
The consequence follows in Hebrews 10:18:
"Now where remission of these is, there is no more offering for sin."
These statements establish the foundation of everything that follows. The offering has accomplished its purpose, remission has been provided, and the former necessity of continuing sacrifices for sin has been overcome. The writer then proceeds to explain the consequence for those sanctified by that offering.
Hebrews 10:19–22:
"Having therefore, brethren, boldness to enter into the holiest by the blood of Jesus, By a new and living way, which he hath consecrated for us, through the veil, that is to say, his flesh; And having an high priest over the house of God; Let us draw near with a true heart in full assurance of faith, having our hearts sprinkled from an evil conscience, and our bodies washed with pure water."
The word therefore connects the brethren's entrance to the sacrifice already explained. They have boldness to enter because Christ's offering has accomplished what the former sacrifices could not accomplish. Their entrance is by His blood, through the new and living way He has consecrated.
Who performs this consecration? Jesus Christ. What does He consecrate? The new and living way. Through what is that way opened? The veil, identified as His flesh. For whom is it consecrated? For us — the brethren who are invited to draw near.
This is the governing distinction which must be preserved throughout the investigation.
The passage does not describe Christ consecrating Peter, John, James or the other apostles into a sacrificial order so that they may subsequently offer Him on behalf of their fellow believers. It describes Christ consecrating the way through which those apostles, together with the brethren, may approach God.
The Greek strengthens rather than weakens the distinction. In Hebrews 10:20, the verb enekainisen (ἐνεκαίνισεν), translated by the KJV as "hath consecrated," concerns the inauguration or dedication of the way. Its object is hodon (ὁδόν), the way. The apostles are not the grammatical object of the consecration. The consecrating action is directed towards the access Christ has opened.
There is an important connection with Hebrews 9:18, where the writer states:
"Whereupon neither the first testament was dedicated without blood."
The Greek verb translated "dedicated" belongs to the same verbal family as that translated "consecrated" in Hebrews 10:20. The former covenant was inaugurated with blood; the new and living way is inaugurated through Christ's flesh, with access explicitly grounded in His blood. Hebrews thus establishes a relationship between covenantal inauguration, sacrificial blood and entrance into the divine presence.
The first covenant was inaugurated with the blood of sacrificial animals, and its sanctuary was governed by a divinely prescribed priesthood. Under the new covenant, Christ Himself supplies the decisive sacrifice, and the way of approach is established through His own person. Nothing in the grammatical construction turns the apostles into the recipients of a separate sacerdotal consecration.
This is not an attempt to prove that no other apostolic commission could ever have existed merely because Hebrews does not mention one. It is a recognition that the particular consecration Hebrews positively describes is the inauguration of access, not the creation of another class of sacrificing priests. Any claim of a further consecration must therefore establish itself independently, and its alleged function must be reconciled with what Christ's completed consecration has already accomplished.
Hebrews 9:8 explains the previous difficulty: the way into the holiest had not yet been made manifest while the first tabernacle was standing. Under the old arrangement, access was restricted, and Hebrews 9:7 describes the high priest entering the second part of the sanctuary once every year with blood. But Christ's sacrifice addresses precisely that condition of restricted access.
If the purpose of His self-offering was to consecrate the way through which the brethren may now draw near, what necessity remains for a sacrificial order whose defining responsibility is to offer Him? Why should the brethren require another earthly sacrificial mediation when Hebrews explicitly attributes their boldness of entrance to His own blood?
The apostles could be teachers, shepherds, witnesses and ministers without their being additional sacrificers of Christ. These are different offices and functions, and the distinction is essential. The sacrifice through which Peter was sanctified was not offered by Peter. The way through which Peter approached God was not consecrated by Peter. He entered by the blood of the same High Priest who opened that way for the entire household of faith.
If Peter himself needed Christ's consecrated way in order to enter, how could Peter's apostolic authority be treated as proof that he was separately consecrated to offer Christ so that others might enter?
The question becomes even more significant when Hebrews identifies the priest who presides over the opened sanctuary. The brethren have "an high priest over the house of God" (Hebrews 10:21). That priest is Christ. The passage does not identify Peter as another sacrificing priest through whom the other brethren must approach.
Christ is not merely the one who created the opportunity for another sacrificial system to begin. He is the one who consecrated the way, provided the sacrifice, and continues to exercise the priesthood through which His people approach the Father.
THE HIGH PRIEST WHO ENTERED BEFORE THE BRETHREN
Hebrews 6:19–20 introduces another important aspect of Christ's ministry. The writer describes the believer's hope as entering within the veil, where Jesus has entered as the forerunner, having been made a High Priest for ever after the order of Melchisedec.
The description of Christ as forerunner is especially revealing. He entered before His people, and their hope reaches within the veil because He has already entered for them. His priesthood secures their approach; it does not merely establish a sanctuary in which successive generations of earthly sacrificers must perform additional offerings.
Hebrews 9:11–12 describes His entrance as taking place by His own blood, through which He obtained eternal redemption. Hebrews 9:14 further identifies His offering as being made "through the eternal Spirit," distinguishing the efficacy of His sacrifice from the blood of animals and explaining its power to purge the conscience.
This is the priestly work of Christ Himself. The means are His own blood, the offering is His own person, and the redemption obtained is eternal.
Hebrews 8:1–2 then places His continuing ministry in the heavenly sanctuary:
"We have such an high priest, who is set on the right hand of the throne of the Majesty in the heavens; A minister of the sanctuary, and of the true tabernacle, which the Lord pitched, and not man."
Here is the High Priest of the new covenant, exercising His ministry in the sanctuary established by God. His priesthood is not dependent upon an earthly successor assuming His office when He dies, because His resurrection means that death cannot terminate His ministry.
Hebrews 7:23–25 makes this contrast explicit. Under the former arrangement, there were many priests because death prevented them from continuing. Christ, however, continues for ever and therefore possesses an unchangeable priesthood. He is able to save those who come to God by Him (not through Mary or dead saints) because He ever lives to make intercession for them.
This presents a profound problem for any supposed necessity of continuing earthly sacrificial mediation. The previous priesthood required succession precisely because its priests died. Christ's priesthood is distinguished by the fact that He lives and continues His work without interruption.
Catholic theology does not claim that its priests replace Christ as High Priest; it claims that they participate in His priesthood. But the distinction between Christ's own perpetual ministry and another man's claimed power to offer Christ remains decisive. Participation in the life and service of Christ is not, without further divine institution, authority to perform His sacrifice.
Scripture certainly records the apostles being chosen and commissioned. But being chosen to proclaim the Gospel does not automatically mean receiving the particular priestly office occupied by Christ. The Father's oath establishes the identity and permanence of Christ's priesthood. It cannot simply be extended to another class of sacrificing men without evidence that such an extension was instituted.
Hebrews 2:11 describes Christ as the one who sanctifies and His people as those who are sanctified, explaining that He is not ashamed to call them brethren. Hebrews 3:1 addresses the holy brethren as partakers of the heavenly calling and directs their attention to Jesus Christ, the Apostle and High Priest of their profession.
The relationships are clear. Christ sanctifies; His people are sanctified. Christ ministers as High Priest; His people approach God through Him. Christ sends His apostles; they testify to His saving work.
Their participation in His mission does not establish that they possess His particular power of sacrificial self-offering.
AT THE LAST SUPPER, CHRIST APPOINTED THE APOSTLES TO A KINGDOM
This brings us to Rome's claimed first link: the Last Supper.
The Council of Trent, Session XXII, Chapter I, held on 17 September 1562, teaches that Christ constituted the apostles priests of the New Testament at the Last Supper and commanded them and their successors to offer His body and blood. Canon II of that session expressly attaches an anathema to the denial that the words "Do this in remembrance of me" instituted the apostles as priests authorised to offer Christ.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 1337, repeats the conclusion that the command to celebrate the Eucharist constituted the apostles priests of the New Testament. Paragraph 611 also connects Christ's self-offering with the institution of their "New Covenant priesthood" .
These statements establish Rome's doctrine, but they do not remove the need to examine the Gospel account itself. The Church's later declaration that a priesthood was instituted is not the same evidence as Christ's own words establishing precisely what He appointed the apostles to become.
In Luke 22:19, Christ says:
"This do in remembrance of me."
The command directs the apostles to continue the action He has demonstrated in remembrance of Him.
What does the New Testament itself say about the continuing observance?
Paul explains in 1 Corinthians 11:26 that the believers, through eating the bread and drinking the cup, proclaim the Lord's death until He comes. His explanation identifies remembrance, participation and proclamation. It does not say that an apostolic sacerdotal character is required because the celebrant must offer Christ's body and blood to God as a propitiatory sacrifice.
The timing also matters. Christ spoke these words before His crucifixion. Hebrews 9:15–18 connects the inauguration of the new testament with death and the shedding of blood, while the Gospel narrative records the apostles receiving the command before Christ's offering at Calvary had been completed.
But there is something even more remarkable in Luke's account, and it concerns the very calling Christ explicitly appoints to the apostles at that supper.
Luke 22:24–27 records a dispute among them concerning which should be accounted the greatest. Christ responds by contrasting worldly lordship with the service required among His disciples, declaring that the chief should be as one who serves. He then tells them:
Luke 22:29–30:
"And I appoint unto you a kingdom, as my Father hath appointed unto me; That ye may eat and drink at my table in my kingdom, and sit on thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel."
What did Christ expressly appoint to them?
A kingdom.
What did He say concerning their future?
They would eat and drink at His table in His Kingdom and sit upon thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel.
This is extraordinary when considered alongside Revelation, where the redeemed are depicted as kings and priests who reign with Christ, and where the names of the twelve apostles appear in the foundations of New Jerusalem.
At the very supper where Rome locates the institution of a sacrificial priesthood, Luke also records Christ explicitly appointing the apostles to a kingdom, a table and a future judicial responsibility. Their calling is associated with service, fellowship and participation in His reign.
The contrast is worth examining carefully. Christ does not say that they will sit in His Kingdom as an order of sacrificing priests required to offer Him. He says they will eat and drink at His table and sit upon thrones.
This does not exclude every additional commission simply because it is not mentioned in these verses. It does, however, give us a positive account of what Christ said He was appointing, and that account is consistent with the apostles' later representation in Revelation.
How could such an explicit description of their future office be passed over while the command of remembrance is treated as the decisive evidence of another office, whose defining sacrificial power is nowhere expressly stated in the passage?
John's account of Christ's final instructions strengthens this understanding. In John 13, Christ washes the disciples' feet and instructs them in humble service. In John 17:17–20, He prays that they may be sanctified through the Father's truth, explains that He has sent them into the world, and extends His prayer to those who will believe through their word.
John 17:19 states:
"And for their sakes I sanctify myself, that they also might be sanctified through the truth."
The Catechism appeals to this verse in connection with the apostles' New Covenant priesthood. But the stated means of their sanctification is the truth, and their commission concerns being sent into the world. The wider prayer includes those who will subsequently believe through their testimony.
Sanctification for apostolic service cannot simply be equated with consecration to offer Christ sacrificially. The disciples are set apart for their mission, but the passage does not describe an ordination into another order of sacrificers.
There is an essential question which Rome must answer from the institution itself: where did Christ distinguish the apostles from the other brethren by granting them a separate power to offer His body and blood to the Father, rather than appointing them to proclaim, remember and bear witness to the redemption He Himself would accomplish?
AFTER THE ASCENSION, THE APOSTLES SERVED THE RISEN CHRIST
If the apostles had been consecrated at the Last Supper into a sacrificial priesthood, their ministry after Christ's resurrection and Ascension would be a natural place to examine how that office was exercised.
The Acts of the Apostles gives a substantial account of their work, including their preaching, teaching, prayers, appointment of ministers, administration of baptism, breaking of bread and care of the congregations. It does not leave us without evidence of what they understood themselves to have been commissioned to do.
In Acts 1:8, Christ promises that the Holy Ghost will give them power to become His witnesses throughout the earth. Their commission is directed towards testimony concerning the risen Lord.
Even the appointment of Matthias is revealing. Acts 1:20 uses the word bishoprick concerning the office vacated by Judas, but Peter then specifies that the man appointed must have accompanied the disciples during Christ's earthly ministry and become a witness with them of His resurrection (Acts 1:21–22).
The vacant office is thus identified through the need for another apostolic witness. The narrative does not describe Matthias receiving an indelible sacerdotal character or a power to offer Christ. The apostles pray for the Lord to reveal His choice, and Matthias is numbered with the eleven.
The fact that an apostolic office could be filled does not settle the nature of every authority supposedly transmitted through later episcopal succession. Its defining responsibilities must still be established.
In Acts 3:12–16, Peter directs the people away from attributing healing power to himself and towards the risen Christ. In Acts 4:10–12, he proclaims salvation through Christ's name. When preaching to Cornelius, Peter declares in Acts 10:43 that forgiveness is received through Christ by those who believe in Him.
Notice the significance of that preaching. Peter directs his listeners to the saving authority of the risen Christ, not to a sacrificial offering Peter must perform in order to obtain remission for them.
Furthermore, Acts 10:44 records the Holy Ghost falling upon those who heard Peter's words before any apostolic laying on of hands. The event demonstrates that the presence and work of the Holy Ghost cannot be reduced to an ecclesiastical mechanism requiring a prior rite of sacerdotal consecration.
When the apostles themselves define the duties requiring their continuing attention, Acts 6:4 records their commitment to prayer and the ministry of the word. In Acts 15:11, Peter again locates salvation in the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ.
These are not incidental activities performed alongside a more fundamental but unmentioned sacrificial office. They are the ministries through which the apostolic commission is repeatedly expressed.
Paul's description of his own service in Romans 15:16 is particularly important because it actually employs priestly language. He describes his Gospel ministry to the Gentiles and speaks of the Gentiles themselves becoming an acceptable offering, sanctified by the Holy Ghost.
What an extraordinary contrast with the assumption that priestly ministry must mean offering Christ sacrificially. Paul uses priestly imagery for the work of bringing people to God through the Gospel, but the offering identified in the passage is the converted people, not Christ's body and blood.
The same distinction applies to the ministries Christ established in the Church. Ephesians 4:11–12 identifies apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors and teachers as gifts for the perfecting of the saints and the edification of Christ's body. In 1 Corinthians 12:28, Paul describes God appointing various ministries and gifts in the Church.
The New Testament therefore possesses a rich vocabulary of ministry without making a separate sacrificial power the defining function of its leaders.
Nor can the laying on of hands resolve the question. Timothy is reminded of a gift associated with the laying on of hands (2 Timothy 1:6), and elders are appointed for the care of congregations. But neither the presence of a spiritual gift nor appointment to oversight automatically establishes an indelible character authorising a man to offer Christ as a sacrificial victim.
The particular authority claimed must be demonstrated, not inferred from the existence of an appointment.
ALL YE ARE BRETHREN — LEADERSHIP WITHOUT A SACRIFICIAL CASTE
Christ's instruction concerning the relationships among His disciples is essential to understanding what the apostles' ministry was intended to accomplish.
In Matthew 23:8–12, He warns against the pursuit of religious titles and exalted status, perhaps like "hierachy", reminding His disciples that they are brethren and that the greatest among them must be their servant.
This does not eliminate distinctions of responsibility. The New Testament plainly recognises elders, overseers and teachers, but it consistently describes their responsibilities in terms of service to the household of God.
Peter's own language is especially relevant. In 1 Peter 5:1–4, he addresses the elders as one who is himself an elder and a witness of Christ's sufferings. He instructs them to feed the flock, exercise oversight willingly and avoid being lords over God's heritage. He then identifies Christ as the chief Shepherd, to whom the elders will answer.
Peter does not describe himself as the possessor of an independent sacrificial priesthood through which the other brethren must approach God. He locates himself among the elders and points them to Christ as the ultimate Shepherd.
Likewise, Acts 20:28 charges overseers to feed the Church which God purchased with His own blood. The blood belongs to the redemption by which the Church (HIS redeemed people) was purchased, while the overseers' responsibility is to care for those purchased people.
This distinction between sacrifice and service becomes clearer in 1 Peter 2:5, where all believers are called a holy priesthood offering spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ. Verse 9 calls them a royal priesthood, a holy nation and a peculiar people, appointed to declare the praises of the one who called them out of darkness.
Here priesthood is attributed to the people of God themselves. Their offerings are spiritual, and their purpose includes proclaiming God's praise.
Hebrews 13:15–16 identifies sacrifices of praise, doing good and sharing with others as offerings pleasing to God. Romans 12:1 speaks of presenting our bodies as living sacrifices, holy and acceptable to God.
None of these offerings requires the believer to become a sacrificer of Christ.
The distinction is not that Christians have no sacrifices to offer. Rather, the nature of their sacrifices has changed. They offer praise, thanksgiving, obedience, good works, generosity and lives dedicated to God because Christ has already accomplished their redemption.
What need is there for a second class of men whose defining priestly work is to offer the Redeemer Himself, when the redeemed have been constituted a priestly people through His completed offering?
But how could the hierarchy maintain their privileged “place” if they acknowledged that Christ Himself had consecrated the way into the holiest for all the brethren, granting them direct access to God through His own blood? If the apostles themselves entered by that same consecrated way, not as a superior class of sacrificing priests but as brethren redeemed by Christ, what justification would remain for a hierarchy claiming an exclusive sacrificial authority inherited from them?
ALL YE ARE BRETHREN — WHOSE AUTHORITY SHALL WE BELIEVE?
Rome attempts to justify its sacerdotal hierarchy by distinguishing between the common priesthood of the faithful and the supposedly superior sacrificial powers of its ordained ministers. Yet this distinction strikes at the very heart of what Christ accomplished. The Son of God declared, "and all ye are brethren" (Matthew 23:8), while Hebrews reveals that He consecrated the new and living way through His own flesh, granting the brethren boldness to enter the holiest by His blood. Peter subsequently addressed believers as "a chosen generation, a royal priesthood, an holy nation, a peculiar people" (1 Peter 2:9). These are not two unrelated promises. The brethren for whom Christ consecrated the way are themselves described as a royal priesthood, whose access to God is secured by the sacrifice of their High Priest. What possible justification remains for introducing another class of men claiming an exclusive sacrificial authority over those whom Christ has already redeemed and admitted through His own blood? If the way is consecrated, the entrance opened, and the royal priesthood established through Christ, what barrier remains for Rome's sacrificing priests to remove?
The contradiction becomes still more serious when we recognise that the apostles themselves belonged among these brethren. They did not stand outside the royal priesthood as another order through which the rest must approach God. They were themselves sanctified through Christ's offering, dependent upon His blood and appointed to proclaim the salvation He had accomplished. Their authority to teach and shepherd did not make them the consecrators of the way, because Christ alone had consecrated it. Yet Rome has constructed a doctrine in which the faithful, though acknowledged as a priestly people, are distinguished from an ordained hierarchy claiming a sacred power to offer Christ which ordinary believers do not possess. But if the royal priesthood already possesses boldness to enter the holiest through Christ, why must it depend upon another priesthood to offer the very sacrifice which opened that entrance? What has Rome's hierarchy been given to accomplish that the Son of God has not already accomplished through His own flesh and blood?
The resemblance between the Roman Catholic hierarchy and the social order of ancient Rome demands far closer examination, for Rome was a civilisation in which wealth, landownership, ancestry and privileged status determined a person's position within society. The senatorial aristocracy possessed immense landed estates and political influence, while membership of the senatorial and equestrian orders was closely associated with property qualifications, family standing and imperial favour. The Roman world was accustomed to distinctions between those who governed and those who obeyed, those who possessed recognised privileges and those who depended upon the authority of their social superiors.
Yet as Christianity became increasingly established within the empire, the Church did not develop in isolation from these structures. Bishops acquired wealth, property, political influence and civic responsibilities, while wealthy aristocratic families became closely involved in ecclesiastical patronage. The Church's hierarchy increasingly reflected the administrative organisation and social distinctions of the imperial society within which it had acquired power.
But what relationship did such a system have to the teaching of Jesus Christ, who declared, "and all ye are brethren" (Matthew 23:8)? Christ did not establish access to His Father according to ancestry, landownership, political position or ecclesiastical dignity. He consecrated the new and living way through His own flesh so that the brethren might enter the holiest by His blood. Peter called those believers "a royal priesthood" (1 Peter 2:9), not an inferior spiritual class whose approach to God depended upon a higher order of human sacrificers. The very people whom Rome distinguishes as possessing only the common priesthood already have access through the consecrated way Christ opened. Their standing before God depends upon the blood of the Son of God, not upon the social position or sacrificial authority claimed by another man.
Here lies the deeper significance of Rome's historical hierarchy. The Roman aristocracy maintained its privileges through distinctions of rank and authority, while the later ecclesiastical hierarchy claimed a different and supposedly sacred distinction between ordained priests and the remainder of the faithful. These systems were not identical: Roman aristocratic rank depended partly upon wealth and property, whereas Catholic ordination claims to confer a spiritual office. Nevertheless, the historical convergence of aristocratic influence, ecclesiastical wealth, episcopal authority and institutional privilege raises a question that cannot be dismissed: how much of the later Church's conception of religious authority reflected Christ's command that the greatest should become a servant, and how much reflected the hierarchical society in which that Church developed?
The issue becomes more serious when the distinction concerns not merely administration but the supposed power to offer Christ sacrificially. The Roman Catholic hierarchy claims an exclusive sacerdotal authority inherited from the apostles, yet the apostles themselves were among the brethren for whom Christ consecrated the way into the holiest. If that way was already opened by His blood, what additional sacrificial power did Peter require to approach God, and where did Christ confer upon him the authority to offer the Redeemer on behalf of the other brethren? The Son of God established the way of access; Rome must establish the divine origin of its claimed sacrificial office.
The existence of an elaborate hierarchy, however ancient or powerful, cannot prove an apostolic consecration that has not first been demonstrated from Christ's institution. Christ, however, established an entirely different principle among His disciples: the greatest was to become the servant, and all were brethren under one Master. Yet the institution centred upon Rome developed an elaborate hierarchy of ecclesiastical dignities, culminating in a "Supreme pontiff" claiming supreme authority over the God's house, while its ordained priesthood claimed a sacrificial power denied to the ordinary faithful. The historical resemblance alone cannot prove that Catholic priesthood was borrowed from Roman social structures, but neither should that resemblance distract us from the more fundamental contradiction being examined. Christ declared the brethren's access through Himself; Rome asserts the necessity of a distinct sacrificial ministry. Christ consecrated the way; Rome claims its priests have inherited authority to offer the one who consecrated it. By whose command was this additional sacerdotal distinction established?
There is a profound historical irony which ought to trouble anyone willing to examine the matter. It was under the authority of the Roman Empire, through the judgment of Pontius Pilate and the actions of Roman soldiers, that Jesus Christ was crucified. The later Roman Catholic Church is not identical to the Roman state which executed Him, and those institutions must not be confused. Nevertheless, the religious institution that eventually established its supreme ecclesiastical seat in Rome asks believers to accept its authoritative interpretation that Christ instituted a continuing sacrificial priesthood, even though the passages concerning the consecrated way expressly direct the brethren to Christ's own blood and priesthood. Whose words, then, shall govern our faith: those of the Son of God, who declared that all are brethren and opened the holiest through His own sacrifice, or the doctrinal claims of a hierarchy established within the Roman world, insisting upon a further sacrificial authority which must still be demonstrated from His commands? The geographical and historical inheritance of Rome cannot bestow authority which Christ never granted, and no ecclesiastical decree can supersede what He accomplished.
The question is not whether Christ's Church requires elders, overseers, teachers or servants, for Scripture establishes those ministries. The question is whether the royal priesthood, whose members already possess access to God through the consecrated way, requires a separate class of sacrificers to offer Christ on its behalf. To establish an order of service is one thing; to claim an exclusive power to offer the Redeemer is quite another. If Christ never conferred that sacrificial office upon Peter and the other apostles, then the bishops of Rome could not have inherited it through apostolic succession. No succession of ordinations, no claims of indelible priestly character, and no centuries of ecclesiastical supremacy can supply an original divine consecration that was never given. The issue therefore reaches beyond the legitimacy of particular Roman pontiffs to the foundations of the entire sacerdotal system: if Christ Himself consecrated the way for His royal priesthood, what divine necessity remains for a hierarchy claiming the power to offer Him?
The brethren do not need another sacrifice to open what Christ has opened, another high priest to replace the one who lives for ever, or an unproved sacrificial hierarchy to grant them the access His blood has already secured. They are called to draw near through Him, to offer their spiritual sacrifices unto God, and ultimately to serve and reign with the Lamb whose blood redeemed them. If Rome claims that Christ nevertheless instituted an additional sacerdotal authority, the burden of proving that claim rests upon Rome. The royal priesthood has already been shown the consecrated way, and the question is whether men will trust the finished work of the Son of God or accept an ecclesiastical claim that has yet to demonstrate its authority from His words.
REVELATION: THE LAMB IS THE REDEEMER, AND THE REDEEMED ARE HIS PRIESTS
We must now follow the argument into Revelation, because the final vision of the Kingdom reveals something of extraordinary importance concerning the relationship between Christ, the apostles and the priestly people He has redeemed.
The question is no longer simply what the apostles did during their earthly ministry. We must examine what Scripture says the redeemed become through Christ's blood, how they serve God, and what place the apostles occupy in the final city.
Revelation 1:5–6 begins with the identity and work of Jesus Christ, who loved His people and washed them from their sins in His own blood. It then declares that He made them kings and priests unto God and His Father.
Notice the sequence. Christ washes them through His blood, and He makes them kings and priests.
The priestly standing of the redeemed proceeds from the blood of the Redeemer. They do not become priests by acquiring a separate power to offer the Lamb. Their priesthood is a blessing bestowed through His completed redemptive work.
This directly corresponds with the consecrated way in Hebrews. Christ's blood provides access, and those redeemed through it are brought into a priestly relationship with God.
Revelation 5 develops the same relationship in the heavenly throne room. John sees the Lamb standing as one who had been slain, and the heavenly song celebrates the redemption accomplished through His blood.
Revelation 5:9–10:
"For thou wast slain, and hast redeemed us to God by thy blood out of every kindred, and tongue, and people, and nation; And hast made us unto our God kings and priests: and we shall reign on the earth."
The Lamb is the one slain. His blood is the price of redemption. The people redeemed through that blood are made kings and priests, and their appointed future is to reign.
There is no intervening class of sacrificers in this description, and no division between people who may approach God because they possess a sacrificial character and people who require that priestly character to be exercised on their behalf.
The distinction concerns their relationship to the Lamb. He redeems; they are redeemed. He grants them priestly standing; they serve God. He reigns; they are appointed to reign with Him.
How can this be made into evidence that some among them were ordained to offer the Lamb as a sacrifice? The vision gives the Lamb an entirely different place in the relationship. He is the source of their redemption and the one whose victory they share.
The blood of the Lamb brings the redeemed before the throne
Revelation 7:14–15 describes those who have come through great tribulation. Their robes have been washed and made white in the blood of the Lamb, and therefore they stand before God's throne and serve Him in His temple.
That word therefore reveals the relationship between redemption and access.
They are before the throne because they have been cleansed through the Lamb's blood. Their service follows from that cleansing.
The vision does not show a human priest standing between them and God to make the Lamb's sacrifice present so that they may enter. Their presence is explained by the blood in which their robes have been washed.
This is not a denial that believers receive teaching or participate in worship while upon earth. It is the positive identification of the sufficient redemptive ground upon which the redeemed stand before God.
Revelation 12:11 further describes the faithful overcoming through the blood of the Lamb and the word of their testimony. The combination is revealing: the saving blood belongs to Christ, while the testimony belongs to those who witness to Him.
This corresponds closely to the apostles' ministry after the Ascension. They bore witness to the risen Christ and proclaimed the redemption accomplished through His blood. Their work directed people towards the Redeemer rather than establishing themselves as another order of sacrificers.
The redeemed are firstfruits unto God and the Lamb
Revelation 14:4 contains another striking description:
"These were redeemed from among men, being the firstfruits unto God and to the Lamb."
The language of firstfruits belongs to a biblical vocabulary of dedication and offering, but its direction here is significant.
The redeemed are firstfruits unto God and to the Lamb.
The Lamb is not being identified as the sacrificial victim whom these redeemed people are authorised to offer. He is named with God as the one to whom the redeemed belong.
This is an important distinction because sacrificial language does not necessarily mean that the person described as a priest must be offering Christ. People themselves may be presented as offerings dedicated to God, just as Paul employs priestly imagery for the Gentiles brought to faith.
Revelation's imagery therefore supports a form of priestly identity centred upon redemption, belonging, dedication and service, rather than requiring the existence of an additional priesthood offering the Redeemer.
Priests of God and of Christ — reigning with Him, not sacrificing Him
Now consider Revelation 20:6, one of the most important passages in the entire investigation:
"Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection: on such the second death hath no power, but they shall be priests of God and of Christ, and shall reign with him a thousand years."
This passage does not merely call the redeemed priests. It tells us whose priests they are and identifies their relationship to Christ in the Kingdom.
They are priests of God and of Christ, and they reign with Him.
Christ is the one whom they serve and with whom they reign. He is not depicted as the sacrificial victim whom these priests must continually offer.
This is a crucial distinction. A priest in the sense described by Revelation is not necessarily a sacrificer of Christ. The very people who are called priests are shown sharing His reign, belonging to Him and exercising the privileges resulting from redemption.
If the apostles were appointed to serve Christ in His Kingdom, what possible connection does that appointment have with an alleged authority to offer Him sacrificially upon earth?
The fact that earthly ministries and heavenly service are not identical must be acknowledged. A Catholic theologian might argue that a temporary earthly sacramental ministry need not continue in the final Kingdom. But that observation does not establish that Christ instituted such a ministry in the first place.
Revelation demonstrates something more fundamental: priesthood in the New Covenant can be described in terms of belonging to God, serving Christ and reigning with Him without any indication that its members possess authority to offer Christ as a sacrificial victim.
Therefore, Rome cannot move from the scriptural existence of priesthood to the conclusion that Christ established the particular sacrificing priesthood which Roman Catholic ordination is intended to perpetuate.
The office and its functions must be proved separately.
Revelation 3:21 promises the overcomer a place with Christ in His throne, while Revelation 22:5 describes His servants reigning for ever and ever. These passages reinforce the direction of the redeemed person's calling: fellowship with Christ, participation in His victory and service under His reign.
Christ does not redeem His people in order that they may become perpetual sacrificers of Him. The heavenly visions portray them as those who share in the life and Kingdom made possible by His sacrifice.
THE APOSTLES WERE APPOINTED TO A KINGDOM — NOT TO SACRIFICE THE KING
There is a further distinction in Revelation which cannot be overlooked, because it concerns not merely the identity of the redeemed as priests, but the time and purpose of their priestly service in Christ's Kingdom. When Christ spoke to His apostles at the Last Supper, He did not merely instruct them concerning the bread and the cup. He also expressly declared what He was appointing them to inherit. In Luke 22:29–30, He said, "And I appoint unto you a kingdom, as my Father hath appointed unto me; That ye may eat and drink at my table in my kingdom, and sit on thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel." Here Christ explicitly identifies their future appointment: they will share His table, receive authority in His Kingdom and sit upon thrones. These are not the duties of men appointed to sacrifice their King, but the privileges of those called to serve and reign under His authority.
This becomes especially significant when we turn to Revelation 20:6, where John declares concerning those who partake in the first resurrection, "they shall be priests of God and of Christ, and shall reign with him a thousand years." Notice that their future priestly service is expressly joined to their reign with Christ. They are not described as priests who offer Christ, but as priests of God and of Christ, sharing in the Kingdom of the very one whose blood redeemed them. The distinction is fundamental. The Lamb is not placed upon an altar by these resurrected priests; He is the reigning Lord whom they serve. Their appointment is not to sacrifice Him, but to belong to Him, serve Him and reign with Him.
Revelation 1:5–6 has already declared that Christ washed His people from their sins in His own blood and "hath made us kings and priests unto God and his Father." Their priestly standing, therefore, begins with redemption, while Revelation 20:6 reveals its future expression in the resurrection and reign of Christ. This distinction between present standing and future service is essential. It would be inaccurate to say that the redeemed possess no priestly identity until the Kingdom comes. Yet their present priesthood is not described as an authority to offer Christ sacrificially, and their future priesthood is expressly associated with serving and reigning with Him. At neither stage does Revelation identify a separate class commissioned to offer the Lamb as a sacrificial victim for the remaining brethren.
Now consider what this means for the apostles. Christ appointed them to a Kingdom, commissioned them to bear witness to His resurrection, and promised them a place of authority in His future reign. Revelation subsequently depicts the priestly redeemed reigning with Christ, while Revelation 21:14 identifies the twelve apostles of the Lamb in the foundations of New Jerusalem. Their promised inheritance is therefore consistent with their earthly calling as foundational witnesses and servants of Christ. Where, in this progression from apostolic commission to resurrection and Kingdom, does Scripture establish their consecration into a separate sacrificial priesthood authorised to offer Christ Himself? Their authority to preach, shepherd and oversee the brethren cannot simply be converted into an authority to perform the sacrifice through which those same brethren were redeemed.
And here we must return to the decisive words of Hebrews 10:19–20. Christ consecrated the new and living way through His own flesh, and the brethren were given boldness to enter the holiest by His blood. The apostles belonged among those brethren. They were not the object of that consecration; they were among its beneficiaries. Their future place in Christ's Kingdom does not transform them retrospectively into sacrificers of the Redeemer. Rather, the scriptural account moves from the way Christ consecrated, to the brethren who enter through Him, to the redeemed who serve in His presence and reign with Him.
If the apostles were appointed to serve Christ upon earth and to reign with Him in His Kingdom, what establishes the claim that they were also consecrated into a sacerdotal office whose defining function was to offer Him sacrificially? The issue is not whether the apostles possessed authority, because Christ unquestionably gave them authority. It is whether that authority included the particular sacrificial power which Rome claims its bishops and priests have inherited. If Christ never conferred that sacrificial priesthood upon the apostles, then no succession of Roman bishops could inherit it from them. Succession cannot transmit a power absent from the original office, however many generations of ordination may subsequently claim to preserve it.
The final picture is therefore profoundly different from the sacerdotal hierarchy Rome claims to continue. Christ is the Lamb whose blood redeemed the brethren, the High Priest who consecrated their way into the holiest, and the King with whom the resurrected saints shall reign. The apostles are His commissioned witnesses, appointed to His Kingdom and honoured in the foundations of His holy city. The redeemed are His priestly people, called to serve God and Christ. The Lamb is the one they serve, not the sacrifice Revelation appoints them to offer. If the bishops of Rome claim succession to a different kind of priesthood, the burden remains upon them to establish when Christ instituted it, whom He consecrated into it, and how its sacrificial power could have descended from apostles whose recorded commission and promised Kingdom inheritance do not establish that office.
The apostles are foundations of New Jerusalem
Revelation 21:14 gives the apostles a particular and enduring place:
"And the wall of the city had twelve foundations, and in them the names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb."
Their names are written in the foundations of the holy city. Their relationship to the Lamb is foundational, consistent with their unique commission as witnesses and their responsibility in the establishment of the Church.
Ephesians 2:20–22 likewise describes believers as built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ Himself being the chief corner stone. The whole building grows into a holy temple in the Lord and becomes a habitation of God through the Spirit.
The distinction is remarkable. Christ is the corner stone, the apostles are associated with the foundation, and the redeemed form the building in which God dwells.
Their foundational ministry does not require that they should have received an additional authority to offer Christ sacrificially.
And this brings us back to Christ's words at the Last Supper. He appointed the apostles to a kingdom, spoke of their place at His table and promised them thrones in His Kingdom. Revelation presents their names in the foundations of New Jerusalem, while the redeemed are described as reigning with Christ.
The two accounts fit together without introducing a distinct sacrificial office.
The apostles' honour is not diminished by recognising that they were witnesses, servants and foundational ministers rather than sacrificers of the Lamb. Their extraordinary calling remains intact. What is challenged is Rome's assertion that their authority included a separate power to offer Christ and transmit that power through generations of bishops.
God and the Lamb are the temple
Revelation 21:22 brings the examination to its ultimate conclusion:
"And I saw no temple therein: for the Lord God Almighty and the Lamb are the temple of it."
The old sanctuary arrangement had a place of restricted access, priestly ministrations and prescribed sacrifices. The final vision of New Jerusalem reveals the Lord God Almighty and the Lamb as the temple itself.
Revelation 21:3 announces the dwelling of God with His people, while Revelation 22:3–4 describes the throne of God and the Lamb, His servants serving Him and seeing His face.
The people redeemed through Christ's blood serve in the divine presence. There is no separate order depicted as offering Christ to obtain entrance for the others, and no need to cross another barrier through a priest's sacrificial authority.
The way Christ consecrated has accomplished precisely what it was intended to accomplish: His people are brought to God.
Even Revelation's heavenly altar imagery does not alter this conclusion. Revelation 5:8 identifies incense with the prayers of saints, while Revelation 8:3–4 depicts incense ascending with those prayers before God. The imagery is of worship and intercession. It does not describe the apostles offering Christ's body and blood as a sacrifice.
And Revelation 19:9 speaks of those blessed to be called to the marriage supper of the Lamb. The language is of participation in a divinely prepared celebration, not the establishment of an additional class whose office is to sacrifice the Lamb.
The total picture is consistent. The Lamb redeems. His people are cleansed. They become priests unto God. They serve in His presence, reign with Christ and inherit the blessings of the Kingdom. The apostles occupy a foundational place in the city of the Lamb.
If that is what the apostles' commission and the redeemed priesthood ultimately lead towards, where does Scripture identify their supposed appointment to become a separate order of men offering Christ sacrificially?
The absence of such a description in Revelation alone cannot establish that no earthly sacramental ministry exists. But when the final vision is read alongside Hebrews' explanation of the consecrated way and Acts' account of apostolic service, a coherent picture emerges which does not require the sacrificing office Rome claims.
ROME'S SACRIFICIAL PRIESTHOOD AND THE QUESTION OF NECESSITY
The Roman Catholic response must be stated accurately if the argument against it is to withstand examination.
The Catechism, paragraphs 1362–1367, teaches that the Eucharist is the sacramental memorial of Christ's unique sacrifice. It does not claim that Christ dies again at every Mass, nor that an entirely different sacrifice is offered. Rather, it teaches that the one sacrifice of Calvary is made present and offered sacramentally through the ministry of ordained priests.
Paragraphs 1545–1548 further explain that the ministerial priesthood participates in Christ's one priesthood. The ordained priest is said to act in persona Christi Capitis, in the person of Christ the Head, while the common priesthood of believers is distinguished from the ministerial priesthood.
This is a more substantial theological claim than the accusation that Catholic priests simply crucify Christ again. Rome expressly denies that it multiplies Calvary into separate historical sacrifices.
Yet its explanation introduces the very question which must be resolved. If Christ's one offering has already obtained eternal redemption and consecrated the way through which the brethren approach God, what divine necessity or command establishes that ordained men must offer that sacrifice sacramentally?
To say that the Mass makes Christ's sacrifice present is to describe the Catholic understanding of the rite. It does not, by itself, prove that Christ instituted an apostolic office with the authority to perform that offering.
To say that the priest acts in the person of Christ is to state the claimed effect of ordination. It does not, by itself, establish that Christ gave the apostles such a sacrificial character.
To say that the ministerial priesthood serves the common priesthood is to explain its intended purpose. It does not establish why the common priesthood, already given access through the blood of Christ, requires a further class of men authorised to offer Him sacrificially.
John 11:48 (KJV):
“If we let him thus alone, all men will believe on him: and the Romans shall come and take away both our place and nation.”
If the religious authorities feared losing their place when people believed in Christ, what happens to the claimed necessity of a separate sacrificial hierarchy when the brethren recognise that Christ Himself has already consecrated their way into the holiest?
WHAT, THEN, DID PETER TRANSMIT?
The historical question of apostolic succession must be examined without confusing different kinds of authority.
Early Christian writings provide evidence that the apostles appointed ministers and that provision was made for the continuation of church leadership.
1 Clement, chapters 42 and 44, describes the apostles preaching the Gospel, appointing bishops and deacons, and making provision for other approved men to succeed in ministry. The text also uses language associated with priestly service and offerings.
This is genuine early evidence for ordered ministry and succession; it should not be disregarded or misrepresented. But it raises rather than eliminates the precise question at issue: what was the nature of the office transmitted?
An office of oversight is not automatically an office possessing authority to offer Christ sacrificially. Evidence that bishops succeeded bishops does not independently establish that the original apostles received the particular sacerdotal character defined by later Roman doctrine.
The Didache, chapter 14, describes the Christian gathering for the breaking of bread and thanksgiving using language of a pure sacrifice. Ignatius of Antioch, writing in To the Smyrnaeans, chapter 8, emphasises the bishop's authority concerning the Eucharistic gathering.
These sources show that sacrificial language and episcopal oversight were present in early Christian discussions of worship. It would therefore be historically inaccurate to claim that early Christians never connected worship with sacrifice or that episcopal responsibility appeared only in the medieval Church.
Nevertheless, sacrificial language can encompass thanksgiving, praise, dedication and the spiritual offerings of believers. Its presence does not automatically settle the later doctrinal question of a priest empowered through an indelible sacramental character to offer Christ's body and blood as a propitiatory sacrifice.
The distinction matters because Rome's claim is not merely that its bishops succeeded early Christian leaders. It claims that its ordained ministers inherited an authority originally bestowed upon the apostles by Christ Himself.
The Council of Trent, Session XXIII, Chapter I, declares that the apostles and their successors received the power to consecrate, offer and administer Christ's body and blood. Canon IV further defends the doctrine that ordination impresses a permanent character.
But the existence of these later doctrinal definitions does not resolve their biblical foundation.
If the apostles were never given the claimed power to offer Christ, successive ordinations cannot establish that they possessed it.
An uninterrupted chain may preserve a genuine office, but it cannot create retrospectively an authority which was absent from the original commission.
Peter could authorise elders to shepherd the brethren. He could appoint ministers to teach and oversee congregations. He could transmit instructions concerning the Gospel, worship and the care of Christ's people.
But if Peter himself had not received a separate sacrificial consecration, he could not transmit that supposed sacrificial power as an inheritance of his own apostolic office.
This does not depend upon proving that every Roman bishop was incorrectly appointed to ecclesiastical leadership. It depends upon establishing whether the particular authority Rome claims was ever bestowed upon the first supposed holders of that authority.
Even a perfect historical succession of bishops would not answer that prior question.
The consequence is profound: if the sacrificial priesthood was never instituted in the apostles, then the Roman pontiffs cannot be successors to that sacrificial priesthood, however long their succession in ecclesiastical office may have continued.
Nor can later ordination ceremonies establish the missing original consecration merely by declaring that they confer it. Their claimed authority depends upon the very institution whose existence must first be demonstrated.
A CONSECRATED WAY CANNOT BE REPLACED BY AN UNPROVED SACRIFICIAL OFFICE
We must now return to the point from which the investigation began, because every element considered has a bearing upon the distinction Christ established.
The old sanctuary arrangement involved restricted access and a divinely appointed priesthood offering sacrifices. Hebrews explains how Christ's sacrifice surpassed that arrangement, obtaining eternal redemption and opening the holiest through His own flesh.
The people for whom the way was consecrated are addressed as brethren. Their entrance is by His blood, their High Priest is Christ, and they are instructed to draw near.
The apostles belonged among those brethren, although Christ also gave them an exceptional commission as His witnesses and foundational ministers. Their commission did not make them the authors of the consecrated way, nor did their ministry supply the blood through which they themselves approached God.
At the Last Supper, Christ commanded remembrance of His approaching sacrifice, taught the apostles the necessity of humble service, and expressly appointed them to a kingdom in which they would share His table and exercise judgment.
After His Ascension, they proclaimed His resurrection, preached remission through His name, ministered the word, prayed, established congregations and appointed others to care for the brethren.
The New Testament called all believers a holy and royal priesthood, identifying their sacrifices with spiritual service acceptable to God through Jesus Christ.
And Revelation disclosed the ultimate destination of the redeemed: cleansed through the Lamb's blood, they stand before God's throne, serve Him, share in Christ's reign and inherit a city whose foundations bear the names of the twelve apostles.
The Lamb is the Redeemer throughout this account. His blood purchases the people. His victory establishes their priestly standing. His throne becomes the centre of their eternal service.
The distinction between serving Christ and offering Christ is therefore not a minor matter of terminology. It concerns the identity of the priesthood, the nature of its ministry and the relationship between the Redeemer and those He has redeemed.
The apostles' earthly commission and their promised place in the Kingdom can be understood through preaching, service, witness, foundational authority and participation in Christ's reign. Those functions are expressly described by Scripture.
A further authority to offer the Lamb sacrificially must be established separately.
The argument does not rest upon the claim that Hebrews 10:20, considered in isolation, excludes every conceivable appointment of the apostles to another office. It rests upon a cumulative investigation of what Christ consecrated, what the apostles were commissioned to do, what the New Testament describes as the priestly sacrifices of believers, and what Revelation reveals concerning the redeemed in the presence of God.
If Rome wishes to identify apostolic ministry with a separate sacrificial priesthood, it must demonstrate the institution of that specific authority rather than assume that all ministry, all priestly language and all succession necessarily possess the same meaning.
For the succession of an office can establish only the continuity of an office that actually existed.
If Christ consecrated the way rather than consecrating the apostles to offer Him, and if the apostles received no further divine commission to exercise that particular sacrificial power, then the Roman bishops inherited no such power from them. The alleged sacerdotal succession would have no valid first link.
The issue is therefore not resolved by counting Roman pontiffs, tracing episcopal ordinations, invoking an indelible priestly character or declaring that an ordained minister acts in Christ's person. All those claims depend upon establishing the original authority which they purport to continue.
The final question is one that no claim of historical succession can evade:
When Christ consecrated the new and living way through His own flesh, opened the holiest by His blood, and brought the brethren into the presence of God, what remained for another sacrificial priesthood to accomplish that His own offering and perpetual priesthood had not already secured?
If the apostles' appointed destiny was to serve the Lamb, bear witness to His redemption and reign with Him in His Kingdom, where is the divine command transforming them into an order authorised to offer that same Lamb sacrificially?
And if Peter never received such an office, who, in that particular sacrificial priesthood, could the bishops of Rome possibly have succeeded?
The consecrated way leads to Christ, not to a succession of human sacrificers. The question Rome must answer is whether its claimed sacrificial authority truly originated with Him, or whether it has attributed to the apostles an office which their own recorded commission and the New Testament's description of priesthood do not establish.
The way was consecrated. The brethren were given access. The Lamb was slain and now reigns. The burden of proof rests upon those who claim that Christ nevertheless instituted another class of men to offer Him.


Comments